The Alvin Public House
Master Critic Review
The Alvin Public House
8.3
The Alvin Public House is a cozy Lenox Hill pub where the burger program sits alongside Irish-influenced comfort dishes, Guinness, and cocktails. Regulars talk about the Alvin Burger and Smash Burger as serious neighborhood contenders, served in a dimly lit room with booths, a back dining area, and some outdoor seating that works for both casual dates and small groups.
Must-Try Dishes:
Alvin Burger (50/50 short rib–brisket blend with bacon, pepper jack, onion ring, garlic-herb aioli), Pub Burger on brioche with fries or salad, Smash Burger with optional double patty and cheese
Scores:
Value: 7.4
Service: 8.6
Consistency: 7.8
Food Quality: 8.4
Atmosphere: 8.3
Cultural Relevance: 6.4
What makes it special: Irish-leaning neighborhood pub where the signature Alvin Burger anchors a strong burger lineup.
Who should go: Burger fans who also want pints, cocktails, and a lively pub room.
When to visit: Weeknight happy hour or late-evening weekends when the bar is buzzing.
What to order: Alvin Burger, Pub Burger, Smash Burger with fries or onion rings.
Insider tip: Ask for the Alvin Burger cooked medium and grab a table in the brighter back room if you want a slightly quieter experience.