0 Followers
Eleven Madison Park
Master Critic Reviews (10 Lists)
Eleven Madison Park
9.0
A formal, art-deco tasting-menu institution where precision and pacing are the product as much as the food. The room is built for milestone nights and high-stakes hospitality, with a choreographed service style that rarely slips.
Must-Try Dishes:
Seasonal tasting menu (chef’s full progression), House bread + cultured butter service, Dessert course progression
Scores:
Value: 6.8
Service: 9.5
Consistency: 9.1
Food Quality: 9.2
Atmosphere: 9.1
Cultural Relevance: 9.2
What makes it special: A three-star-level tasting experience defined by choreography and detail.
Who should go: Milestone diners and serious food travelers
When to visit: Celebrations; earlier seating for smoother pacing
What to order: Tasting menu; wine pairing; signature dessert course
Insider tip: Plan for a long meal—arrive un-rushed and fully on time.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Limited street parking in Flatiron; expect difficulty after 6pm. Paid garages nearby are the most reliable option. Valet is sometimes available for dinner service—confirm when booking.
Dress code: Formal-leaning smart dress. Jackets are common and appropriate; jeans are generally discouraged. Treat it like a milestone evening rather than a casual night out.
Noise level: Low and controlled—quiet enough for focused conversation, with service pacing intentionally calm.
Weekend wait: Reservation required; walk-ins are rarely accommodated.
Weekday lunch: Reservation required; no meaningful walk-in availability.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — the tasting menu is fully plant-based.
Vegan options: Yes — the entire experience is designed around vegan cuisine.
Gluten-free options: Yes — accommodations are routinely handled with advance notice.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if it’s intentionally high-stakes. The experience is long, formal, and immersive—better for established chemistry than casual discovery.
Can I get a table without a reservation? No, not realistically. Eleven Madison Park operates on a reservation-only model and plans service precisely around booked guests.
Is it kid-friendly? Not recommended. This is a multi-hour, quiet tasting experience best suited for adults and older teens celebrating a special occasion.
Best For
Better for: Choreographed fine dining, milestone celebrations, and guests who value service precision as much as cuisine.
Skip if: You want flexibility, a shorter meal, à la carte ordering, or a more spontaneous, relaxed dining atmosphere.
Eleven Madison Park
9.0
A formal tasting-menu institution where precision, pacing, and hospitality choreography are as central as the food. It’s built for milestone nights and high-stakes dining, with a dining room that rewards arriving on time and leaning fully into the experience.
Must-Try Dishes:
Tasting menu, Signature seasonal vegetable course, Dessert course finale
Scores:
Value: 7.1
Service: 9.3
Consistency: 9.2
Food Quality: 9.4
Atmosphere: 9.2
Cultural Relevance: 9.1
What makes it special: A tasting-menu masterclass where choreography and detail are the product.
Who should go: Milestone diners and serious food travelers
When to visit: Earlier seating for smoother pacing
What to order: Tasting menu, pairing, dessert finale
Insider tip: Arrive un-rushed—being early helps the whole meal land better.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No valet. Limited street parking in Flatiron; garages nearby but expensive—plan to use a garage or rideshare.
Dress code: Formal to dressy. Jackets strongly recommended; this is not a jeans-and-sneakers room.
Noise level: Low and refined—conversation is easy and the room stays controlled.
Weekend wait: No walk-ins expected; reservations are required and often booked weeks in advance.
Weekday lunch: Lunch service varies by season; when offered, reservations are still required.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes—fully supported through the tasting menu.
Vegan options: Yes—entirely plant-based tasting menu with equal focus and ambition.
Gluten-free options: Yes—accommodated with advance notice; staff handles dietary needs at a fine-dining level.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if it’s a serious first date. The experience is long, formal, and high-pressure—great for bonding if you’re aligned, awkward if not.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Highly unlikely. This is a reservation-only destination; cancellations sometimes appear last-minute, but walk-ins should not be expected.
Is it kid-friendly? Not recommended. The multi-hour tasting format and formal atmosphere are best suited for adults and older teens celebrating something specific.
Best For
Better for: Milestone celebrations, once-in-a-lifetime meals, and diners who value precision, pacing, and hospitality as much as food.
Skip if: You want flexibility, à la carte ordering, a casual vibe, or a shorter meal—this is a commitment dining experience.
Eleven Madison Park
9.2
A hushed, special-occasion dining room where pacing, precision, and ceremony do most of the romantic work. It’s built for couples who want an immersive night with long arcs, quiet focus, and a sense of being taken care of from start to finish.
Must-Try Dishes:
Chef’s tasting menu, Bread course, Dessert course
Scores:
Value: 6.7
Service: 9.4
Consistency: 9.2
Food Quality: 9.3
Atmosphere: 9.1
Cultural Relevance: 9
What makes it special: A ceremony-driven tasting night with elite pacing and polish.
Who should go: Anniversary couples who want full immersion
When to visit: Early seating for the calmest, most romantic pace
What to order: Tasting menu, beverage pairing, add the signature supplements
Insider tip: Mention the occasion—small touches land big here.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No on-site valet. Multiple paid garages within 1–2 blocks; street parking is extremely limited, especially after 6pm.
Dress code: Elegant, upscale attire expected. Jackets and dresses feel appropriate; avoid casual or athletic wear.
Noise level: Low and hushed — ideal for quiet, uninterrupted conversation.
Weekend wait: Reservation-only; no walk-in availability is typical.
Weekday lunch: Reservation-only; occasional same-day cancellations but do not rely on walk-ins.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — the entire tasting menu is plant-based.
Vegan options: Yes — fully vegan tasting menu with thoughtful substitutions if needed.
Gluten-free options: Yes — accommodated with advance notice; staff is highly detail-oriented.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Usually not ideal for a first date. The long, formal tasting format leaves little flexibility and works best once you already know each other.
Can I get a table without a reservation? No. Reservations are essential and should be secured well in advance.
Is it kid-friendly? No. This is an adults-only, occasion-driven dining experience without kid accommodations.
Best For
Better for: Milestone celebrations, anniversaries, and couples seeking a deeply ceremonial, once-in-a-lifetime dining experience.
Skip if: You want spontaneity, à la carte flexibility, or a relaxed, conversational date-night vibe.
Eleven Madison Park
9.2
A three-star, ceremony-driven tasting-menu room where precision, pacing, and calm hospitality do most of the heavy lifting. The cooking is technique-forward and vegetable-led, with optional protein courses that keep the experience flexible without losing its signature discipline.
Must-Try Dishes:
Full tasting menu (seasonal), Honey-lavender duck (optional course), Mille-feuille without butter (seasonal)
Scores:
Value: 6.9
Service: 9.3
Consistency: 9.2
Food Quality: 9.5
Atmosphere: 9.1
Cultural Relevance: 9.4
What makes it special: A world-class tasting menu built around pacing, technique, and ritual.
Who should go: Special-occasion couples who want full immersion
When to visit: Early seating for the calmest, smoothest pacing
What to order: Full tasting, optional protein course, pairing if you commit
Insider tip: Mention the occasion when booking for thoughtful touches.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No on-site valet; limited street parking and metered spots nearby. Most guests use rideshare or nearby garages around Madison Square Park.
Dress code: Smart elegant. Jackets are common but not required; avoid casual wear like shorts or sneakers.
Noise level: Low and controlled — ideal for quiet conversation and focused dining.
Weekend wait: Reservation-only; walk-ins are extremely unlikely to be accommodated.
Weekday lunch: No wait with reservation; walk-ins rarely available.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — the core tasting menu is fully vegetable-driven.
Vegan options: Yes — the menu is entirely plant-based with optional supplements.
Gluten-free options: Yes — accommodations are routine and handled seamlessly with advance notice.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if you already know you’re aligned. It’s long, intimate, and serious — better for established chemistry than casual discovery.
Can I get a table without a reservation? No. Reservations are essential and typically booked well in advance.
Is it kid-friendly? Not recommended for children. The experience is lengthy, quiet, and designed for adult attention spans.
Best For
Better for: Ceremony, pacing, and a calm, immersive tasting-menu experience where hospitality and discipline are the main event.
Skip if: You want à la carte flexibility, faster meals, or a lively, social dining atmosphere.
Eleven Madison Park
9.2
A ceremony-driven tasting menu where the luxury is precision: pacing, technique, and hospitality that feels engineered for anniversaries. The cooking is plant-based and highly controlled, so the best nights come when you lean into the full progression and let the room’s calm do the work.
Must-Try Dishes:
Tasting menu (seasonal progression), Signature bread and spreads course, Dessert course finale
Scores:
Value: 7
Service: 9.5
Consistency: 9.3
Food Quality: 9.4
Atmosphere: 9.1
Cultural Relevance: 9.1
What makes it special: A full-ritual tasting experience built around flawless pacing and precision.
Who should go: Anniversary couples and milestone celebrators
When to visit: Early seating for calm pacing
What to order: Full tasting, optional pairing, dessert finale
Insider tip: Mention the occasion at booking for extra care.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No on-site valet; nearby paid garages within a few blocks. Street parking is extremely limited and unreliable after 6pm.
Dress code: Upscale elegant. Jackets are common and recommended; jeans are acceptable if paired with a polished top, but most guests lean formal.
Noise level: Low and hushed — designed for focused conversation and an intimate, ceremonial feel.
Weekend wait: Reservation-only; no meaningful walk-in availability.
Weekday lunch: Limited seatings by reservation; occasional last-minute openings if you check day-of.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — the entire tasting menu is plant-based by design.
Vegan options: Yes — fully vegan tasting menu with no substitutions required.
Gluten-free options: Yes — accommodations are standard and handled seamlessly when noted in advance.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if you already want something serious. The experience is long, quiet, and immersive, which can feel intense for a first meeting but exceptional for established chemistry.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Highly unlikely. This is a destination restaurant with fixed seatings; plan well in advance and monitor cancellations if you’re flexible.
Is it kid-friendly? Not recommended. The long tasting format, quiet room, and formal pacing are best suited for adults and milestone celebrations.
Best For
Better for: Anniversaries, once-in-a-lifetime celebrations, and diners who value ritual, pacing, and hospitality as much as the food itself.
Skip if: You want à la carte flexibility, protein-forward menus, or a lively, social dining room — consider more relaxed fine-dining alternatives instead.
Eleven Madison Park
9.2
A destination-level tasting menu experience built around precision, pacing, and a calm, ceremonial dining room overlooking Madison Square Park. The current plant-forward approach rewards guests who want the full arc—multiple courses, deep technique, and a long, intentional night.
Must-Try Dishes:
Seasonal tasting menu, Signature bread course, Tea + petit fours finish
Scores:
Value: 7
Service: 9.3
Consistency: 9.3
Food Quality: 9.4
Atmosphere: 9.1
Cultural Relevance: 8.8
What makes it special: A once-in-a-lifetime tasting menu built on obsessive technique and pacing.
Who should go: Milestone celebrators and serious tasting-menu diners
When to visit: Weeknights for the calmest, most focused service
What to order: Tasting menu, wine pairing, tea-and-sweets finale
Insider tip: Treat it as the whole night—don’t schedule anything after.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No on-site valet; multiple paid garages nearby around Madison Square Park. Street parking is extremely limited and unreliable, especially after 6pm.
Dress code: Dressy and polished—jackets, dresses, and tailored outfits feel right. No formal requirement, but casual attire will feel out of place.
Noise level: Low and serene—conversation is effortless and the room stays intentionally quiet.
Weekend wait: Reservation required; walk-ins are not realistic
Weekday lunch: Reservation required; availability depends on booking window
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes – the entire tasting menu is plant-forward by design.
Vegan options: Yes – fully vegan tasting menu with optional beverage pairings.
Gluten-free options: Yes – accommodations are handled seamlessly with advance notice.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if you already know each other well. The experience is long, formal, and emotionally focused—better for deep connection than light chemistry testing.
Can I get a table without a reservation? No. This is a reservation-only experience, often booked weeks or months in advance. Plan ahead or watch for rare cancellations.
Is it kid-friendly? Not recommended. The length, cost, and quiet pacing make it best for adults celebrating milestones rather than families with children.
Best For
Better for: Ceremonial, once-in-a-lifetime tasting-menu dining with unmatched pacing, service precision, and narrative flow.
Skip if: You want flexibility, à la carte options, a faster meal, or a more casual, spontaneous night out.
Eleven Madison Park
9.1
A destination-level tasting menu built around technique, pacing, and a tightly controlled dining-room calm—where seasonality and sourcing show up as structure, not decoration. It’s strongest when you treat it like the entire night: arrive ready for the full arc and let the kitchen’s progression do the work.
Must-Try Dishes:
Granola, Soba noodles, Rhubarb mochi
Scores:
Value: 6.8
Service: 9.3
Consistency: 9.2
Food Quality: 9.4
Atmosphere: 9
Cultural Relevance: 9.1
What makes it special: A three-star tasting experience defined by precision and pacing.
Who should go: Milestones, serious diners, and tasting-menu regulars
When to visit: Weeknights for the calmest room
What to order: Tasting menu, beverage pairing, sweets finale
Insider tip: Don’t plan anything after—let the night breathe.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Valet available during dinner service (typically $30–$35). Limited street parking; garages nearby but valet is the smoothest option.
Dress code: Upscale and polished. Jackets aren’t required, but this is a place to lean dressy rather than casual.
Noise level: Low — hushed, controlled, and conversation-focused.
Weekend wait: Reservation-only; walk-ins are extremely unlikely to be seated.
Weekday lunch: Lunch service is limited or seasonal; when offered, reservations are still strongly required.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — the entire menu is plant-forward and built around vegetables.
Vegan options: Yes — fully vegan tasting menu by design.
Gluten-free options: Yes — accommodations are handled seamlessly with advance notice.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if it’s a serious one. The length, formality, and cost make it better for established relationships or milestone moments than casual getting-to-know-you dinners.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Realistically, no. Tables are booked well in advance, and walk-in availability is extremely rare.
Is it kid-friendly? Not really. This is a long, quiet tasting-menu experience best suited for adults and older teens who can commit to the pacing.
Best For
Better for: Guests who want a deeply intentional, plant-forward fine-dining experience where pacing, service choreography, and sourcing philosophy matter as much as flavor.
Skip if: You’re craving spontaneity, à la carte flexibility, or a shorter, more casual meal — or if you want a meat-centric luxury experience.
Eleven Madison Park
9.1
A destination tasting-menu room defined by disciplined pacing and a dining room calm that makes the meal feel like an event. The current experience plays best when you let the kitchen’s sequence lead and treat the night as a full arc rather than hunting for a single “best dish.”
Must-Try Dishes:
Tasting menu progression, Bread service courses, Tea-and-sweets finale
Scores:
Value: 7.1
Service: 9.3
Consistency: 9.3
Food Quality: 9.4
Atmosphere: 9.2
Cultural Relevance: 9.1
What makes it special: A ceremony-level tasting menu built on pacing, restraint, and precision.
Who should go: Milestone diners and tasting-menu regulars
When to visit: Weeknights for the calmest room
What to order: Tasting menu, beverage pairing, sweets finale
Insider tip: Plan nothing after—let the full progression breathe.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Valet available in front of the restaurant (typically $20–$25); limited street parking nearby and difficult in the evenings
Dress code: Upscale and polished — jackets common, elegant attire expected; not black-tie, but definitely dressy
Noise level: Low — hushed, formal dining room where conversation is easy and uninterrupted
Weekend wait: Reservation-only; walk-ins are extremely unlikely
Weekday lunch: Reservation required; occasional same-day availability if you check early
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — the entire tasting menu is vegetarian
Vegan options: Yes — fully plant-based menu with no animal products
Gluten-free options: Yes — accommodations available with advance notice; inform the team when booking
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if you’re both serious diners — the experience is long, formal, and immersive, which can feel intense for a casual first meeting.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Practically no — this is a reservation-driven destination, and planning ahead is essential.
Is it kid-friendly? Not ideal — best for adults and older teens who can sit through a multi-hour tasting menu.
Best For
Better for: Ceremony-level dining, flawless pacing, and a calm, almost theatrical tasting-menu experience where structure matters as much as flavor
Skip if: You want à la carte flexibility, meat-focused menus, or a shorter, more casual luxury meal
Eleven Madison Park
9.2
A ceremony-level chef’s table experience where pacing and composition matter as much as flavor, delivered in a dining room that feels engineered for focus. The best version is total commitment—arrive ready for the full arc, keep distractions minimal, and let the kitchen’s sequence build the night instead of hunting for a single “best dish.”
Must-Try Dishes:
Honey-lavender duck (when offered), Celebration of tomato (seasonal), Bread course with house-made spreads
Scores:
Value: 7
Service: 9.1
Consistency: 9.3
Food Quality: 9.4
Atmosphere: 9.2
Cultural Relevance: 9
What makes it special: A three-star tasting menu built on precision, restraint, and pacing.
Who should go: Milestones and tasting-menu regulars
When to visit: Weeknights for the calmest room
What to order: Full tasting menu, beverage pairing, signature seasonal highlights
Insider tip: Plan nothing after—this meal is the whole night.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No on-site valet. Nearby paid garages around Madison Square Park; street parking is very limited, especially after 6pm.
Dress code: Smart elegant. Jackets, dresses, and polished footwear feel appropriate; casual wear stands out.
Noise level: Low. Designed for focus and conversation—voices stay hushed and the room is intentionally calm.
Weekend wait: Reservation required; walk-ins are extremely unlikely for the chef’s table.
Weekday lunch: Chef’s table typically operates by reservation only; no reliable walk-in availability.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — the core experience is fully plant-based.
Vegan options: Yes — the entire tasting menu is vegan by design.
Gluten-free options: Yes — accommodations are handled seamlessly with advance notice.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if it’s a serious, high-trust date. The experience is long, quiet, and immersive—better for established chemistry than casual getting-to-know-you energy.
Can I get a table without a reservation? No. The chef’s table is tightly controlled and reservation-only. Plan well in advance and be flexible on dates.
Is it kid-friendly? Not recommended. This is an adult, ceremony-driven experience best suited for mature diners who can commit to the full pacing.
Best For
Better for: Guests who value pacing, precision, and a fully immersive tasting-menu arc over theatrics or choice-driven dining.
Skip if: You want flexibility, à la carte options, or a lively, social atmosphere—this is about focus, not buzz.
Eleven Madison Park
9.1
A ceremony-level tasting experience where pacing, precision, and quiet control are the point—not a single “best dish.” For private dining, it works best when you let the kitchen run the arc, keep the table focused, and treat the night like a composed performance.
Must-Try Dishes:
Carrot Tartare, Smoked Sturgeon, Chocolate Covered Pretzel
Scores:
Value: 6.9
Service: 9.2
Consistency: 9.1
Food Quality: 9.4
Atmosphere: 9.1
Cultural Relevance: 9
What makes it special: A private-dining-capable tasting room engineered for focus and pacing.
Who should go: Milestones and tasting-menu regulars
When to visit: Weeknights for the calmest room
What to order: Tasting menu, beverage pairing, sweets finale
Insider tip: Plan nothing after—make this the entire night.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No valet. Nearby garages on E 24th–26th Streets; street parking is very limited and unreliable after 6pm.
Dress code: Elegant and polished. Jackets are common; jeans are technically allowed but will feel out of place in private dining.
Noise level: Low – engineered for focus and conversation, especially in private rooms.
Weekend wait: Not applicable – private dining is reservation-only.
Weekday lunch: Not applicable – private dining is reservation-only.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes – full vegetarian tasting menus available with advance notice.
Vegan options: Yes – fully vegan menus are a core part of the experience.
Gluten-free options: Yes – accommodated seamlessly with advance notice.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Not ideal. The experience is long, formal, and highly focused—better for established relationships or milestone moments than early chemistry.
Can I get a table without a reservation? No. Private dining requires advance booking and coordination; walk-ins are not an option.
Is it kid-friendly? Generally no. This is a ceremony-level experience best suited for adults; children would likely find the pacing and length challenging.
Best For
Better for: Unmatched pacing, composure, and sense of occasion for private celebrations where the meal itself is the event.
Skip if: You want flexibility, à la carte ordering, or a lively, social atmosphere—choose a high-end brasserie or steakhouse instead.