30 Photos
ZipPicks Awards
Best French Fries in San Francisco
Best Seafood in San Francisco
Best American in San Francisco
Best Wings in San Francisco
Best Brunch in San Francisco
Master Critic Review
Pier 23 Cafe Restaurant & Bar
7.8
A weathered Embarcadero seafood shack where the setting does as much work as the kitchen—open-air beer garden, bay views, and live jazz Thursday through Sunday pull groups who want waterfront energy over fussy plating. The crab and shrimp sandwiches anchor a straightforward menu built for sunny-day drinking and sharing, and the decades-long run on the pier gives it a neighborhood gravity that newer waterfront spots haven't earned yet.
Must-Try Dishes:
Shrimp Sandwich, Crab Sandwich, Louie Salad
Scores:
Value: 7.5
Service: 7.5
Consistency: 7.8
Food Quality: 7.8
Atmosphere: 8.5
Cultural Relevance: 8
What makes it special: Waterfront seafood shack directly on the Embarcadero with live jazz and an open-air beer garden overlooking the bay
Who should go: Groups wanting waterfront seafood with live jazz and bay views
When to visit: Sunny afternoons for the outdoor beer garden experience
What to order: Start with the Smoked Rillette, split a Crab Sandwich and Shrimp Sandwich between two, add a Louie Salad for the table
Insider tip: Grab a seat in the beer garden before the live jazz sets start for the best waterfront spot on the Embarcadero
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No on-site lot—street meters along the Embarcadero are scarce and competitive; Pier 19 Garage is a 1-minute walk, with several other garages within 0.2 miles; pre-booking recommended on weekends
Dress code: Total come-as-you-are—plastic patio chairs, picnic tables, and a waterfront beer garden; shorts and flip-flops fit right in
Noise level: Live music Thu–Sun nights gets loud on the indoor side; the outdoor patio and beer garden are more relaxed when bands aren't playing, but expect a lively buzz on sunny afternoons
Weekend wait: Sunny weekends pack the patio—groups of 5+ must call ahead to reserve; walk-ins should arrive early or expect a wait for outdoor seating
Dietary Options
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Better for a fun, energetic date than a quiet romantic one. Pier 23 features live music six nights a week — jazz, salsa, R&B, reggae — and the main room gets loud with shoulder-to-shoulder dancing during peak hours. The back patio overlooking the bay is considerably quieter and offers great sunset views, making it the best spot for conversation. Request patio seating if you want to actually talk. Ideal for a casual, upbeat first date where you both enjoy live music and waterfront cocktails — not for a hushed, candlelit evening.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Walk-ins are possible given the casual, bar-forward vibe, especially on weekdays and during daytime hours. Weekends with live music draw crowds, so booking ahead is smart — reservations are available through their website. The back patio is the most in-demand seating, so reserve if that's where you want to sit. For parties of 11 or more, you must call directly at (415) 362-5125. Current hours are Wednesday through Sunday, 11:30am–4:30pm for table service on the patio — confirm evening hours directly as they vary with live music events.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes — Pier 23 has a dedicated family page on their website and offers a kids menu. The casual, no-frills waterfront atmosphere means kids won't feel out of place. The outdoor patio is spacious and dog-friendly, giving restless little ones room to breathe. The laid-back daytime vibe is best for families; evening hours skew louder with live music and a bar crowd, so plan for lunch or early afternoon visits with young children. High chair availability not confirmed online — call ahead if needed.
Is it good for groups? Yes — one of the better group options on the Embarcadero. Pier 23 has multiple indoor and outdoor spaces available for private events including weddings, birthdays, reunions, and work gatherings. One dining room opens on three sides in warm weather or encloses with heaters when it's cool. A separate uncovered area has shade umbrellas and heaters. For parties of 11 or more, call directly to book. For private events, email events@pier23cafe.com. The casual vibe and spacious layout make it easy to accommodate large groups without feeling cramped.
Is there outdoor seating? Yes — extensive outdoor seating across multiple areas. Sidewalk tables out front offer views of Telegraph Hill above the palm-lined Embarcadero. The Beer Garden faces Treasure Island across the bay. The back patio sits waterside with direct bay views. Some areas can be covered with heaters for cooler evenings; others are open-air with colorful umbrellas for shade. The patio is dog-friendly. This is one of San Francisco's better waterfront outdoor dining spots — the bay views are the main draw.
Best For
Better for: Waterfront day drinking with a group—sun, bay views, and cold beers are the real draw, not the food; great for casual hangs, not a destination dinner
Consider Alternatives If: You want a memorable meal—the food is serviceable but not the star; this is a drinks-and-vibes stop, not a culinary one
Hours
Monday11:30am - 7:30pm
TuesdayClosed
Wednesday11:30am - 7:30pm
Thursday11:30am - 7:30pm
Friday11:30am - 7:30pm
Saturday11:30am - 7:30pm
Sunday11:30am - 7:30pm