0 Followers
Pancoast Pizza
Master Critic Reviews (4 Lists)
Pancoast Pizza
7.9
Independent shop turning out New York–style whole pies and slices at wallet-friendly prices. Straightforward counter flow keeps takeout moving on busy nights.
Must-Try Dishes:
Pepperoni NY pie, White pie, Grandma square
Scores:
Value: 9
Service: 7.6
Consistency: 8
Food Quality: 8.1
Atmosphere: 6.4
Cultural Relevance: 7.2
What makes it special: Dependable NY slices with friendly pricing and hours.
Who should go: Budget-minded pizza families
When to visit: Early evening before peak pickup rush
What to order: Pepperoni; white pie; Grandma square
Insider tip: Call ahead for whole pies to skip the line.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking along South Main is usually available before 6pm; nearby city garage at 1350 Locust offers free first hour.
Dress code: Casual — jeans, T-shirts, and ball caps are totally fine.
Noise level: Moderate — you can hold a conversation, but expect lively takeout chatter.
Weekend wait: 10–20 minutes for slices; up to 30 minutes for whole pies during prime hours.
Weekday lunch: Typically no wait; fast counter turnaround.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — multiple meat-free pies including white, Margherita, and veggie combos.
Vegan options: Limited — no dedicated vegan cheese, but plain red-sauce pie works if requested.
Gluten-free options: No dedicated gluten-free crust; cross-contact possible.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if you’re aiming for low-key and casual — quick slices and a no-pressure vibe work better for informal meetups than romantic dinners.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes. Seating is first-come, first-served at the small dine-in counter; most guests take food to go.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes — families frequent it for quick, affordable dinners. Booths and counter seating accommodate strollers easily.
Best For
Better for: Quick, inexpensive slices and friendly local service compared with chain competitors.
Skip if: You’re seeking patio dining, cocktails, or specialty-diet crusts — nearby Gusto Mio or Montesacro offer more upscale experiences.
Pancoast Pizza
7.9
Husband-and-wife shop turning out New York–style whole pies and slices at wallet-friendly prices. Straightforward counter flow means quick pickup on busy nights.
Must-Try Dishes:
Pepperoni Pie, White Pie, Grandma Square
Scores:
Value: 8.7
Service: 7.7
Consistency: 8.3
Food Quality: 8.1
Atmosphere: 6.8
Cultural Relevance: 7.6
What makes it special: Independent slice shop with dependable pricing and hours.
Who should go: Budget-minded pizza families
When to visit: Early evening before the takeout rush
What to order: Pepperoni NY; white pie; Grandma square
Insider tip: Call ahead for whole pies to skip the counter line.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Small shared lot directly behind the building plus metered street spots along South Main; easy before 6pm, tighter after dinner hours.
Dress code: Completely casual — jeans, hoodies, and team shirts are the norm.
Noise level: Low to moderate — mostly takeout traffic, light background chatter when dine-in tables fill.
Weekend wait: 10–15 minutes for a whole pie during the rush, slices usually immediate.
Weekday lunch: No wait for slices; 5–10 minutes for full pies.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — cheese, margherita, and white pies are popular picks.
Vegan options: Limited — can request no-cheese veggie slice but no vegan cheese offered.
Gluten-free options: No dedicated gluten-free crust; cross-contact likely in shared ovens.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Not ideal unless your date loves casual, no-frills pizza joints; better suited for quick hangs or pre-movie bites.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes — it’s counter-service only, so seating is first-come and quick turnover keeps spots open.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes — simple menu, fast service, and slice options make it easy for kids; high chairs limited but booths fit families.
Best For
Better for: Faster service and lower prices than nearby sit-down pizza spots like Melo’s or Montecatini.
Skip if: You’re after cocktails, polished service, or an extended dine-in experience — it’s built for speed, not ambiance.
Pancoast Pizza
7.9
Neighborhood spot doing New York–style pies and slices at friendly prices. Reliable for takeout on game nights and quick lunches on South Main.
Must-Try Dishes:
Thin-crust pepperoni, White pie with ricotta, Grandma square
Scores:
Value: 8.7
Service: 7.6
Consistency: 8.1
Food Quality: 8.2
Atmosphere: 6.5
Cultural Relevance: 7.8
What makes it special: Straightforward NY slices with dependable pricing and hours.
Who should go: Budget-minded slice traditionalists
When to visit: Early evening before peak pickup rush
What to order: Pepperoni; white pie; Grandma square
Insider tip: Call ahead for whole pies to skip the counter line.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Shared lot with nearby shops plus limited street parking on South Main; usually open spots mid-afternoon and after 8pm.
Dress code: Completely casual — tees, hoodies, and sneakers are the norm.
Noise level: Moderate during lunch rush or big games, quieter in the early evening.
Weekend wait: 10–15 minutes for slices; 20–30 minutes for whole pies during prime hours.
Weekday lunch: Usually no wait except for fresh slice rotation.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes – classic cheese, margherita, and white pies are solid picks.
Vegan options: Limited – can request cheeseless veggie slices, but no vegan cheese.
Gluten-free options: No gluten-free crust currently offered.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? More of a casual hang than a date spot — fine for a laid-back, slice-and-chat kind of meet-up.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes, walk-in only. Counter seats and small tables usually turn over quickly.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes — families often stop by for early dinners. High chairs and quick service make it easy for younger kids.
Best For
Better for: Fast, affordable NY slices without the fuss or wait of trendier downtown pizzerias.
Skip if: You’re after patio dining, craft cocktails, or gourmet toppings — it’s a no-frills slice shop.
Pancoast Pizza
7.9
Vibes:
Family Friendly Favorites
Quick Bites Champions
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Hidden Gems Heaven
No-frills New York–style slices and whole pies with quick counter service. Crisp foldable slices and friendly staff make it a reliable budget option near South Main.
Must-Try Dishes:
NY Pepperoni, White Pie, Garlic Knots
Scores:
Value: 8.4
Service: 7.6
Consistency: 7.8
Food Quality: 8.1
Atmosphere: 6.6
Cultural Relevance: 7.4
What makes it special: Classic New York foldable slices at wallet-friendly prices.
Who should go: Families on a quick budget bite
When to visit: Lunch hours before school let-out
What to order: Pepperoni; white pie; garlic knots
Insider tip: Whole pies travel well—order ahead on game nights.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Free lot and nearby street parking along South Main, usually available except during peak dinner rush.
Dress code: Casual—t-shirts, shorts, and ball caps are all fine; it's a relaxed slice shop vibe.
Noise level: Moderate during lunch and early dinner; easy to talk at most tables.
Weekend wait: 10–15 minutes for slices, up to 25 for whole pies during peak hours.
Weekday lunch: Typically no wait—service is counter-style and fast.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes—cheese, white, and veggie pies are always available.
Vegan options: Limited—no vegan cheese, but plain crust and sauce can work for strict vegans.
Gluten-free options: No dedicated gluten-free crust; best to avoid if sensitive.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if you’re both casual pizza lovers—it’s more about grab-and-go slices than ambiance.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes, all seating is first-come, first-served; turnover is quick even at busy times.
Is it kid-friendly? Absolutely—kids love the slice options, and there’s plenty of space for families to sit and share.
Best For
Better for: Quick, authentic New York–style slices at low prices; faster and cheaper than sit-down spots like Melo’s.
Skip if: You’re looking for a dine-in experience with drinks or full-service Italian entrees.