0 Followers
Gus and Marty's
Master Critic Review
Gus and Marty's
8.2
Gus and Marty's is a smoky, high-energy Greek spot off McCarren Park known for hand-stretched pita, dialed-in dips, and a natural-leaning Greek wine list. It feels built for pre-going-out dinners and loud group nights, with share plates and grilled fish that keep the table busy long after the first round of mezze.
Must-Try Dishes:
Hand-Stretched Pita with Taramasalata and Whipped Feta, Moussaka a la Eggplant Parm, Slow-Cooked Lamb Shoulder
Scores:
Value: 6.6
Service: 8
Consistency: 7.8
Food Quality: 8.8
Atmosphere: 8.4
Cultural Relevance: 8.4
What makes it special: A pita-obsessed Greek taverna with big flavors and a serious Greek wine program.
Who should go: Friends planning a lively, share-plate-heavy night near McCarren Park.
When to visit: Prime evening hours when the oven, bar, and music are all in full swing.
What to order: Order the dip spread with hot pita, moussaka a la eggplant parm, and slow-cooked lamb shoulder.
Insider tip: Build your meal around the meze and bread—those dips and hot pitas are where the kitchen shines brightest.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking available, but can be difficult to find after 6pm. Consider using a nearby parking lot.
Dress code: Smart casual, jeans are fine but lean dressy for the evening crowd.
Noise level: High - the space is lively, and conversation may be difficult during peak hours.
Weekend wait: 45-60 min without reservation
Weekday lunch: No wait typically
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes - dedicated menu section with several options.
Vegan options: Limited - 2-3 options available.
Gluten-free options: Yes - separate prep area for gluten-free dishes.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Yes, it's great for a first date due to its lively, fun atmosphere. The share-plate format makes it easy to bond over food without the pressure of an overly formal setting.
Can I get a table without a reservation? It can be tough to get a table without a reservation, especially during weekend dinners. It's best to book in advance.
Is it kid-friendly? The restaurant is more geared toward adults and groups, but kids are welcome. The noise level may not make it ideal for very young children.
Best For
Better for: Gus and Marty's excels in its high-energy vibe, great for groups and pre-night out dinners. Its pita and dips are a standout compared to other Greek spots in the area.
Skip if: If you're looking for a quiet, intimate dinner or a place with a focus on traditional, fine-dining Greek food, consider alternatives.