0 Followers
Croton Reservoir Tavern
Master Critic Review
Croton Reservoir Tavern
7.9
A Midtown tavern that’s more food-forward than it looks, with a menu designed for sharing and a bar program that keeps the room busy past dinner. Come for classic crowd plates—wings, mac, dips—and treat it as a reliable stop for groups who want comfort food and drinks without committing to a formal meal.
Must-Try Dishes:
Wings, Return of The Mac, Artichoke Dip
Scores:
Value: 7.8
Service: 7.7
Consistency: 8.2
Food Quality: 7.9
Atmosphere: 7
Cultural Relevance: 7.2
What makes it special: A share-plate tavern menu that pairs well with cocktails and groups.
Who should go: After-work groups and casual meetups.
When to visit: Happy hour into late evening.
What to order: Wings, mac, artichoke dip.
Insider tip: Go shareable-heavy and skip ordering too many mains.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking is very limited around Bryant Park; nearby public garages are the most realistic option, especially after 6pm.
Dress code: Casual to smart-casual. Jeans, sneakers, and relaxed after-work outfits are all normal here.
Noise level: Moderate to loud during peak hours — fine for groups, tougher for quiet conversation late.
Weekend wait: 30–45 minutes during peak evening hours, shorter late night
Weekday lunch: Little to no wait most days
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — several share plates and sides work well for vegetarians.
Vegan options: Limited — expect to piece together sides rather than full entrees.
Gluten-free options: Some naturally gluten-free options, but no dedicated gluten-free menu.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Better for casual, low-pressure meetups than intimate first dates — the energy skews social and lively.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Usually yes, especially earlier in the evening or late night. Peak happy hour can mean short waits.
Is it kid-friendly? Early evening is fine for older kids who can handle a busy tavern vibe; late night skews adult.
Best For
Better for: Group-friendly comfort food, shareable plates, and lingering over drinks without formality.
Skip if: You want a quiet, date-focused room or a menu built around refined mains instead of bar food.