Master Critic Review
Paperfish Sushi Brickell
8.3
This Tokyo-meets-Lima izakaya opened in 2021 and quickly earned three consecutive Miami New Times 'Best Sushi' awards under Chef Michael Asalie, who won the South Beach Seafood Festival's sushi battle in 2022. The Paper Tuna and torched salmon nigiri draw the crowds, but the Nikkei-leaning menu—think crispy rice with truffle and acevichado rolls—is where the kitchen really distinguishes itself from Brickell's sushi pack. Dinner service gets loud and energetic, which is either the point or a drawback depending on what you're after. Service can feel transactional during peak hours, and some reviewers find the portions modest for the price point. Best suited for date nights where you want quality fish without the omakase commitment or the scene-y peacocking of flashier neighbors.
Must-Try Dishes:
Paper Tuna, 48-Hour Marinated Black Cod, Salmon Aburi Nigiri
Scores:
Value: 8
Service: 8
Consistency: 8.2
Food Quality: 8.5
Atmosphere: 8.3
Cultural Relevance: 8
What makes it special: Tokyo-inspired izakaya blending Nikkei flavors with inventive nigiri like torched wagyu and truffle-kissed salmon in a sleek Brickell setting.
Who should go: Date-night couples and groups seeking shareable Nikkei plates
When to visit: Hit happy hour for drink specials and lighter crowds
What to order: Start with crispy rice and Paper Tuna, move to torched nigiri selections, then share the miso black cod family-style before finishing with a wasabi martini.
Insider tip: Ask for the omakase if you want the chef to curate your experience—it's off-menu but available.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking available nearby, plus a parking garage. Rates approx $5 lunch, $10 dinner
Dress code: Smart casual—Tokyo izakaya vibe, jeans and a nice top work fine
Noise level: Lunch is calm; dinner gets lively with a fun party vibe—sit inside if you prefer quieter
Weekend wait: Reservations recommended—popular spot that fills up
Weekday lunch: Generally easy to get a table
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Limited options available—ask server for current offerings
Vegan options: Vegan options available—romantic ambiance noted by vegan diners
Gluten-free options: Check website for updated information
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Yes. The sophisticated space with open-air terraces creates both intimate and social vibes. The contemporary Japanese-Nikkei menu offers plenty of shareable plates for conversation, and the atmosphere works well for lunch, happy hour, or dinner dates. Request terrace seating for a more romantic feel.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Reservations recommended, especially for dinner and weekends. You can book online or call (305) 741-0936. The restaurant is popular (4.8 stars from 1,100+ diners), so walk-ins may face waits during peak hours. Lunch and early dinner are easier for walk-ins.
Is it kid-friendly? Possible with planning. Consider an earlier seating, plan to share plates, and call ahead to confirm menu flexibility for kids. The South Beach location has a dedicated kids menu—call Brickell to confirm their specific offerings for children.
Is it good for groups? Yes. They offer dedicated group dining spaces for small or large parties. For large groups, contact them directly since online booking may not accommodate big parties. Private events can be arranged through their event booking system.
Is there outdoor seating? Yes. Open-air terraces are available, creating an atmosphere that works for lunch, happy hour, dinner, or late-night dining. The outdoor space is well-integrated into the restaurant's design.
Best For
Better for: Trendy date night with creative Nikkei (Japanese-Peruvian) rolls and great cocktails. The torii gates and cherry blossom decor make it Instagram-worthy
Consider Alternatives If: You want traditional sushi purist experience or need strict gluten-free accommodations
Hours
Monday12pm - 10:45pm
Tuesday12pm - 10:45pm
Wednesday12pm - 10:45pm
Thursday12pm - 10:45pm
Friday12pm - 12am
Saturday4pm - 12am
Sunday4pm - 9:45pm