Skip to main content

Make My Cake
$ · Bakery

409 W 125th St, New York, NY 10027
Are you the owner? Claim this business

ZipPicks Awards

Best Bakery in Harlem

Vibe Check this spot

Food Quality 5
Service 5
Atmosphere 5
Value 5
Consistency 5
Cultural Relevance 5

0 / 5 selected

Master Critic Review

Make My Cake 8.6
Morningside Heights
Vibes: Sweet Treats Escapes Comfort Food Classics Family Friendly Favorites Hidden Gems Heaven
Make My Cake is a Harlem bakery known for moist red velvet cakes, cheesecakes, and an especially praised key lime pie that draw dessert-focused crowds to 125th Street. Locals treat it as the spot for celebration cakes and slices, even if prices run higher than a typical neighborhood bakery.
Must-Try Dishes: Red Velvet Cake, Key Lime Pie, Sweet Potato Cheesecake
Scores:
Value: 6.9 Service: 7.7 Consistency: 8.5 Food Quality: 8.9 Atmosphere: 6.8 Cultural Relevance: 8.8
What makes it special: Harlem’s go-to bakery for bold layer cakes and classic Southern-style slices.
Who should go: Dessert-first locals planning birthdays or special occasions.
When to visit: Afternoons for best selection before popular cakes sell out.
What to order: Red Velvet Cake, Key Lime Pie, Sweet Potato Cheesecake.
Insider tip: If you need a whole cake for a specific day, order ahead—same-day options can sell out fast on weekends.