ZipPicks Awards
Best Late Night Pizza in Chatham
Master Critic Review
Old Chicago Pizza Company
8.2
A South Side takeout-first pizza shop that wins on dependable Chicago-style comfort: thick, cheesy pies and classic topping combos that hold up for delivery. The best results come from keeping the order traditional—one pizza, one side—and eating it hot while the crust still has bite.
Must-Try Dishes:
Deep dish cheese pizza, Sausage & pepperoni pizza, Garlic bread with marinara
Scores:
Value: 8.4
Service: 7.8
Consistency: 8.3
Food Quality: 8.6
Atmosphere: 6.2
Cultural Relevance: 8
What makes it special: Old-school Chicago pizza focus with reliable late-night pickup energy.
Who should go: Night owls craving a real pizza meal
When to visit: After 8pm for late dinner pickup
What to order: Deep dish cheese, sausage & pepperoni, garlic bread
Insider tip: Order online if you want the smoothest pickup.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Mostly street parking nearby; easiest approach is a quick curbside pickup stop if you're grabbing food late. Expect tighter spots on weekend nights, but it’s usually manageable with a short loop around the block.
Dress code: Very casual—hoodies, jeans, and work clothes are all normal. This is a come-as-you-are takeout-and-go kind of spot.
Noise level: Low (for pickup). You’re mainly in and out—short counter interaction, not a place built for lingering conversations.
Weekend wait: 20-40 min for pizza during peak late-night hours (longer for deep dish or big topping builds).
Weekday lunch: 10-20 min for standard orders; faster if you call ahead.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes—easy lane. Stick to cheese or veggie topping builds (peppers, onions, mushrooms) and add a side like garlic bread if you want a full meal feel.
Vegan options: Limited—most pizzas lean heavily on cheese. You may be able to do a no-cheese veggie pie, but it won’t be the signature experience and availability can vary by order setup.
Gluten-free options: Limited/unclear—this is a classic pizza shop format where cross-contact is likely. If gluten-free is a must (celiac-level), it’s safer to choose a dedicated gluten-free operation.
Best For
Better for: Late-night Chicago-style comfort pizza that travels well—thick, cheesy slices and classic topping combos that still eat like a real meal at home.
Consider Alternatives If: You want a dine-in pizza experience, specialty artisan pies, or strict dietary options (true gluten-free or vegan). Choose a sit-down pizzeria or a dedicated dietary-friendly spot instead.