0 Followers
Ammazzacaffè
Master Critic Review
Ammazzacaffè
8.5
This Michelin Bib Gourmand winner surprises with inventive housemade pastas and an extensive amaro program. The candlelit interior leads to a transported-to-Umbria garden patio, while dishes like ondine with shrimp demonstrate refined technique without pretension.
Must-Try Dishes:
Ondine with Shrimp, Reginette with Pancetta, Grilled Branzino
Scores:
Value: 8
Service: 8.5
Consistency: 8.5
Food Quality: 8.8
Atmosphere: 8.5
Cultural Relevance: 8.2
What makes it special: Michelin-recognized Italian with 50+ amaros and a secret garden patio
Who should go: Amaro enthusiasts and romantic dinner seekers
When to visit: Sunday for live jazz 7-9pm
What to order: Any housemade pasta, finish with an ammazzacaffè digestif
Insider tip: The $35 prix-fixe during Grand Street Restaurant Week offers exceptional value
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking in East Williamsburg - generally easier than central Williamsburg. L train to Grand Street or rideshare recommended
Dress code: Smart casual Brooklyn - elevated but relaxed. Jeans work fine, the candlelit interior invites dressing up a bit without requiring it
Noise level: Relaxed and conversation-friendly inside with high ceilings. Sundays 7-9pm feature live jazz on the patio which adds energy but may not suit noise-sensitive diners
Weekend wait: Reservations recommended for weekend patio seating; walk-ins often available inside. The secret garden status means less crowded than central Williamsburg spots
Weekday lunch: Not open for lunch weekdays. Weekend brunch Fri-Sun from noon has minimal wait
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes - seasonal vegetable dishes and pasta options available. Staff accommodating with modifications
Vegan options: Accommodating - chef has prepared special vegan pastas on request and modified appetizers. Alert staff when booking
Gluten-free options: Yes - gluten-free options noted on menu. Discuss with server for specific preparations
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Exceptional choice. The candlelit interior with penny-tiled floors and wildflowers creates instant romance, while the secret garden patio transports you to Umbria. The 50+ amaro selection gives you something to explore together, and Michelin recognition signals taste without being stuffy. The $70/person average (with drinks) hits the sweet spot of impressive but not overwrought.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes - this remains one of Williamsburg's best-kept secrets. Weeknight walk-ins are usually no problem; weekend patio seats fill faster. Call ahead for Saturday dinner or Sunday jazz nights. The Infatuation notes it's 'a solid backup plan when you forgot to book' elsewhere - though that undersells how good it actually is.
Is it kid-friendly? Better suited for adults. The candlelit atmosphere, extensive amaro program, and refined small plates create a date-night environment. Private dining room available for up to 28 people if celebrating with family, and the patio is dog-friendly with heaters and umbrellas for daytime visits.
Best For
Better for: Amaro obsessives, romantic outdoor dining without the reservation battle, and Michelin-quality pasta at neighborhood prices. The $35 prix-fixe during Grand Street Restaurant Week is unbeatable value. The hidden garden patio offers an escape that central Williamsburg Italian spots (Lilia, Misi) can't match
Skip if: You want classic Italian comfort food like carbonara or chicken parm - the menu is inventive and seasonal. If you need reservations months ahead to feel special, this under-the-radar gem may feel too accessible. Closed Tuesdays