0 Followers
Angelo's Pizza
Master Critic Reviews (2 Lists)
Angelo's Pizza
7.9
A coal-oven Broadway pizzeria that balances quick service with sit-down comfort. The crust comes out char-kissed and sturdy enough for classic toppings or house specialties. Great for a casual pre-show meal when you want more than a slice shop.
Must-Try Dishes:
Coal-oven margherita, Meatball parm hero, Calzone with ricotta and mozzarella
Scores:
Value: 8
Service: 7.6
Consistency: 8
Food Quality: 8
Atmosphere: 7.1
Cultural Relevance: 7.4
What makes it special: Coal-oven pies in the heart of Broadway.
Who should go: Pre-show crowds and pizza purists.
When to visit: Early evening before curtain time.
What to order: Margherita, a meaty pie, calzone.
Insider tip: Order a whole pie even for two—leftovers travel well.
Angelo's Pizza
8.3
A no‑frills, family‑friendly spot serving thin‑crust coal‑fired pies in the heart of Midtown; locals grab a slice or whole pie after a night out. The straightforward menu and reliable hours make it a consistent late‑night fallback. Portions and toppings deliver solid value for its price point.
Must-Try Dishes:
Thin‑crust cheese pie, Pepperoni slice, Calzone special
Scores:
Value: 8.2
Service: 8
Consistency: 8.4
Food Quality: 8.5
Atmosphere: 7
Cultural Relevance: 8.1
What makes it special: Simple coal‑fired thin‑crust pies in Midtown nightlife corridor
Who should go: Budget‑conscious late‑night pizza lovers
When to visit: After Broadway shows or late evening out
What to order: Cheese pie, pepperoni slice, house calzone
Insider tip: Ask for extra crispy crust for better foldable slices
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking is available, but can be difficult to find after 6pm. There are also parking garages nearby, with rates typically around $25-40 for a few hours.
Dress code: Casual - jeans and a t-shirt are perfect. No need to dress up for this laid-back spot.
Noise level: Moderate - the atmosphere is lively but you can still comfortably converse with your dining companions.
Weekend wait: Expect a wait of 30-45 minutes on weekends, especially after late theater shows.
Weekday lunch: No wait typically during weekday lunches, as it's less crowded.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes - there are vegetarian options like the Margherita pizza, house salads, and veggie calzone.
Vegan options: Limited - they offer a couple of vegan-friendly pizza toppings, but there aren't dedicated vegan pies.
Gluten-free options: Yes - they offer gluten-free pizza crusts, but it’s important to mention any dietary restrictions to ensure proper prep.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? It’s a casual spot, so if you're looking for something low-key and comfortable, it's a good choice. However, if you're aiming for a more romantic or upscale atmosphere, consider alternatives.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes, but depending on the time, especially on weekends, there may be a wait. It's a good idea to arrive early if you want to avoid peak hours or try to call ahead.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes, it's great for families. The atmosphere is relaxed and the menu has plenty of kid-friendly options like cheese pizza, pepperoni, and calzones.
Best For
Better for: This place excels at delivering a no-fuss, solid late-night pizza experience. If you're looking for quick, satisfying comfort food after a night out, Angelo's is the place.
Skip if: If you're seeking a more refined or innovative pizza experience, or if you're looking for a quiet, intimate setting, you might prefer other options nearby.