Master Critic Review
Baby Jane Cocktail House & Noodle Bar
7.4
A no-frills NY-style slice shop that earns its reputation by staying open until 5am on weekends when everything else in Brickell is closed. The Sicilian squares with their crispy-chewy texture and the classic cheese slice are the main draws—nothing fancy, just solid execution at reasonable prices. Counter service in a compact space next to Better Days bar makes it a natural post-party stop. Some slices land closer to 'elevated frozen pizza' territory than authentic New York, and daytime visits reveal the limitations more clearly. Best for late-night cravings when quality expectations adjust accordingly.
Must-Try Dishes:
Classic Cheese Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza, Chicken Wings
Scores:
Value: 8
Service: 7.5
Consistency: 7.2
Food Quality: 7.3
Atmosphere: 7
Cultural Relevance: 6.8
What makes it special: No-frills NY-style slice shop with late-night hours until 5am on weekends, serving consistently solid pizza when everything else is closed.
Who should go: Night owls and late-night bar crawlers
When to visit: Post-midnight when it becomes the go-to spot
What to order: Keep it simple with a Classic Cheese or Pepperoni slice—this is grab-and-go fuel, not a sit-down experience—add garlic rolls if sharing
Insider tip: Located right next to Better Days bar—perfect for your late-night slice run
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Located at 500 Brickell building—building parking available. Convenient for hotel guests nearby
Dress code: Very casual—late-night pizza joint vibe. Come as you are, even post-club attire welcome
Noise level: Lively atmosphere with cool decor. Good energy, especially late night. Conversation-friendly
Weekend wait: Quick service typical. Located next to Better Days bar—expect post-bar crowds late Fri/Sat
Weekday lunch: Fast service, minimal wait
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Standard options: cheese pizza, veggie toppings available, salads
Vegan options: Call ahead to confirm options
Gluten-free options: Call ahead to confirm availability
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Good for casual, low-key first dates - especially late-night dates after bars. Modern, cozy atmosphere with friendly staff. Not romantic but comfortable. Great option if you're looking for something unpretentious where you can just talk over good pizza.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes - walk-ins are the norm here. Rarely a long wait. They take reservations for larger groups but most people just show up. Located next to Better Days bar, so late nights (Fri-Sat open until 5am) can get busier.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes - listed as family-friendly with a casual, welcoming atmosphere. Sicilian pizza party trays feed 6-8 people, great for families. Best for families during earlier hours; late-night weekend crowds skew toward bar-goers.
Is it good for groups? Yes - group-friendly with party trays that let you choose 4 pizza flavors. Reservations recommended for larger groups during peak hours. Casual atmosphere accommodates celebrations without fuss.
Is there outdoor seating? Yes - outdoor seating available for al fresco dining. Indoor seating also offers a cozy, modern atmosphere.
Best For
Better for: Late night (open until 5am Fri/Sat), post-bar dining, quick NY-style slices, budget-friendly Brickell option, convenience
Consider Alternatives If: You want gourmet/artisanal pizza, need extensive dietary accommodations, or prefer a sit-down dining experience
Hours
Monday11:30am - 12am
Tuesday11:30am - 12am
Wednesday11:30am - 12am
Thursday11:30am - 12am
Friday11:30am - 5am
Saturday11:30am - 5am
Sunday4:30pm - 12am