Best American Restaurants in Long Island City (11101)
5 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: January 2026
Our Top Pick
Court Square Diner
A true all-day diner with proven reliability at massive local volume.
Notable Picks
8.6
A classic, high-volume neighborhood diner that wins on round-the-clock reliability and a menu built for repeat visits. The best move is to order like a regular—one comfort staple, one breakfast favorite, and a side that travels well if you’re taking it to-go.
Must-Try Dishes:
Belgian waffle, French onion soup, Tuna melt
What makes it special: A true all-day diner with proven reliability at massive local volume.
8.4
A New American small-plates spot that rewards decisive ordering and a shareable spread rather than solo mains. The best experience is built around contrast—one richer plate, one bright/acid-driven bite, and something crisp to reset the palate.
Must-Try Dishes:
Seasonal small plates, Chef’s daily specials, Shareable starters
What makes it special: New American small plates designed for sharing and pacing.
#3
The Newsroom
8.3
A speakeasy-leaning cocktail destination with a polished, mood-forward room that works best as a pre-dinner anchor or a full night built around drinks and bites. The right play is to treat it like an experience: arrive early, order two signature cocktails, and add a small plate to keep the pacing clean.
Must-Try Dishes:
Latin-leaning small plates, House cocktail program, Late-night bar snacks
What makes it special: A true speakeasy-style cocktail room with a full experience vibe.
8.2
A counter-service BBQ stop built around smoked-meat satisfaction and a backyard hangout vibe that works especially well for groups. Order with focus—two signature meats plus one standout side—so the meal stays punchy and balanced instead of repetitive.
Must-Try Dishes:
Brisket burnt ends, Beef brisket, Pork ribs
What makes it special: Kansas City–style BBQ with a backyard setup that fits groups.
8.2
A burger-and-beer anchor with a casual, retro-leaning room and the kind of energy that works for a low-effort night out. It’s strongest when you keep the order simple: one signature burger, one side, and a drink that fits the moment.
Must-Try Dishes:
The SWAYZE burger, The WANDA burger, Fries
What makes it special: Burgers-first comfort food with a social bar energy.