What is the best American restaurant in Midtown Manhattan?

Haswell Green's is our top pick for American restaurants in Midtown Manhattan, scoring 8.7/10. A lively setting blending piano tunes with high-end American bites.

Any insider tips for Haswell Green's?

Catch a late-night show for a special musical performance.

When should I visit Haswell Green's?

Great for an evening out with food, drinks, and entertainment.

Who should go to Haswell Green's?

Sports fans, music lovers, and date-night seekers.

Any insider tips for Bartley Dunnes?

Their happy hour deals make it a great spot for after-work drinks.

When should I visit Bartley Dunnes?

Ideal for casual evenings or a laid-back happy hour.

Who should go to Bartley Dunnes?

Beer lovers, casual diners, and fans of great cocktails.

Any insider tips for Tanner Smiths?

The outdoor patio is a great spot during warmer months for brunch.

When should I visit Tanner Smiths?

Perfect for a weekend brunch or evening cocktails.

Who should go to Tanner Smiths?

Cocktail enthusiasts, brunch-goers, and date-night pairs.

Any insider tips for Judge Roy Bean Public House?

Their BBQ Ribs are a must-try, especially if you're a fan of smoky flavors.

When should I visit Judge Roy Bean Public House?

Perfect for a laid-back lunch or evening with friends.

Who should go to Judge Roy Bean Public House?

Pub lovers, casual groups, and sports fans.

Best American Restaurants in Midtown Manhattan (10019)

Q: What should I order at Haswell Green's?

Truffle Fries, Grilled Steak, Lobster Mac and Cheese.

Q: What should I order at Bartley Dunnes?

Gourmet Burger, Craft Beer Flights, Fish Tacos.

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: March 2026

Save

Our Top Pick

Haswell Green's

A lively setting blending piano tunes with high-end American bites.

Notable Picks

#1 Haswell Green's

8.7

$$ Clinton

Vibes: Live Music Showtime Sports Bar Central Date Night Magic

This vibrant American spot doubles as a piano bar and sports bar, offering upscale takes on comfort food like truffle fries and steaks, all while hosting live music performances.

Must-Try Dishes: Truffle Fries, Grilled Steak, Lobster Mac and Cheese

What Makes it Special: A lively setting blending piano tunes with high-end American bites.

View Full Review →

#2 Bartley Dunnes

8.6

$$ Midtown-Times Square

Vibes: Brewery & Beer Garden Republic Girls Night Out Approved Comfort Food Classics

A gastropub with an extensive cocktail menu and an American-inspired menu featuring hearty fare like gourmet burgers and craft brews.

Must-Try Dishes: Gourmet Burger, Craft Beer Flights, Fish Tacos

What Makes it Special: Gourmet pub food paired with creative cocktails in a relaxed setting.

View Full Review →

#3 Tanner Smiths

8.2

$$ Columbus Circle

Vibes: Date Night Magic Brunch Bliss Spots Brewery & Beer Garden Republic

A contemporary cocktail bar offering elevated New American dishes and a great selection of beers, all set in a swanky yet cozy atmosphere.

Must-Try Dishes: Crispy Chicken Sandwich, Avocado Toast, Beer Battered Fish & Chips

What Makes it Special: Modern cocktails with an emphasis on New American classics.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#4 Judge Roy Bean Public House

7.8

$$ Midtown East

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Sports Bar Central Group Dining Gatherings

A cozy pub offering classic American fare in a relaxed environment, complete with an extensive drink menu and a selection of classic pub dishes.

Must-Try Dishes: BBQ Ribs, Classic Cheeseburger, Chicken Wings

What Makes it Special: A great selection of pub food and drinks in a relaxed pub environment.

View Full Review →