Skip to main content

Best American Restaurants in Pasadena (91101)

5 hand-picked restaurants, AI-analyzed and critic-validated

Notable Picks

$$$ South Lake
Upscale farm-to-table dining showcasing California's agricultural bounty with rustic elegance. The kitchen delivers expertly executed seasonal dishes like Mediterranean sea bass and duck, while the intimate fireplace setting creates romance.
Must-Try Dishes: Mediterranean Sea Bass, Duck Confit, Truffle Crusted Chicken
What makes it special: Farm-to-table philosophy with sustainable local sourcing
$$ South Lake
Upscale-casual American bistro delivering refined comfort classics with exhibition kitchen flair. The warm butter cake achieves legendary status while Chilean sea bass and prime steaks showcase culinary expertise.
Must-Try Dishes: Warm Butter Cake, Chilean Sea Bass, Prime Rib Dip
What makes it special: Exhibition kitchen and impeccable hospitality standards
$$ South Lake
Founded in 2003, owner Tom Holt built this cafe around a hearth oven that bakes focaccia dough fresh constantly throughout the day. The scratch kitchen creates gourmet sandwiches and farm-fresh salads with refined local ingredients in a warm yet vibrant counter-service atmosphere.
Must-Try Dishes: UC Chicken Banh Mi, Chimichurri Steak Sandwich, Cilantro Chicken Salad
What makes it special: Scratch-made focaccia baked fresh all day in open-hearth ovens
$$ South Lake
Chef-driven fast-casual restaurant serving scratch-made plates, sandwiches, and salads with sustainably sourced ingredients including grass-fed steak and cage-free chicken. The cafeteria-style service model features real plates and server delivery to tables despite counter ordering.
Must-Try Dishes: Grilled Steak Sandwich, Turkey Avocado Club, Chimichurri Steak Plate
What makes it special: Sustainable scratch-made plates with grass-fed and cage-free proteins

Worthy Picks

$$ Old Pasadena
American classics redefined with made-to-order burgers, creative sandwiches, and over twenty topping options. Fast-casual format with craft beer on tap appeals to millennials and families seeking quality without formality.
Must-Try Dishes: Short Rib Grilled Cheese, Southwest Chicken Sandwich, Ahi Tuna Burger
What makes it special: Twenty+ toppings for burger customization