What is the best American restaurant in Soho?

Estela is our top pick for American restaurants in Soho, scoring 9.0/10. Michelin-starred, high-impact small plates that helped define modern downtown dining.

Any insider tips for Estela?

Bar seats offer the full menu and a slightly easier reservation game.

What should I order at Estela?

Ricotta dumplings, endive salad, a tartare and a seafood plate.

When should I visit Estela?

Prime-time dinner with a reservation for full buzz.

Who should go to Estela?

Seasoned diners chasing inventive, shareable American plates.

Any insider tips for Blue Ribbon Brasserie?

Solo diners can often snag a late walk-in spot at the bar.

What should I order at Blue Ribbon Brasserie?

Fried chicken, bone marrow with oxtail marmalade, seafood plateau.

When should I visit Blue Ribbon Brasserie?

Late evenings into the early hours for full energy.

Who should go to Blue Ribbon Brasserie?

Night owls, industry folks, and classic brasserie obsessives.

Any insider tips for The Corner Store?

Lean into sharing—splitting a steak and a couple of starters stretches value.

What should I order at The Corner Store?

Wagyu French Dip, disco steak frites, Samoa sundae.

When should I visit The Corner Store?

Prime weekend evenings if you can land a reservation.

Who should go to The Corner Store?

Groups and couples chasing buzzy, scene-y downtown dinners.

Any insider tips for Manuela?

Ask about art pieces in the dining room—staff are used to questions.

What should I order at Manuela?

Roasted vegetables, a seasonal fish, and a composed dessert.

When should I visit Manuela?

Daytime for art-lit brunch, evenings for polished dinners.

Who should go to Manuela?

Design-minded diners who care as much about room as food.

Any insider tips for Fanelli Cafe?

Bar stools are prime—watch the room and people-watch Prince Street.

What should I order at Fanelli Cafe?

Fanelli's burger, chili or lamb stew, and a beer or martini.

When should I visit Fanelli Cafe?

Afternoons or early evenings before the bar fully packs in.

Who should go to Fanelli Cafe?

Anyone craving classic bar food in a lived-in NYC room.

Any insider tips for Wicked Willy's?

Reserve for larger groups—prime karaoke and game-viewing spots fill quickly.

What should I order at Wicked Willy's?

Wicked wings, loaded nachos, and a burger or tacos.

When should I visit Wicked Willy's?

Weekend nights or game days for maximum party atmosphere.

Who should go to Wicked Willy's?

Groups prioritizing fun drinks, wings, and music over quiet.

Best American Restaurants in Soho (10012)

6 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Estela

Michelin-starred, high-impact small plates that helped define modern downtown dining.

Essential Picks

#1 Estela

9.0

$$$$ Nolita

Vibes: Date Night Magic Luxury Dining Elite Trendy Table Hotspots Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Opened in 2013 by chef Ignacio Mattos, Estela is a Michelin-starred Nolita dining room known for intensely flavored, shareable plates like ricotta dumplings and endive salad that have become modern NYC signatures. Strong multi-platform ratings, international press, and more than a decade of relevance make it a destination for serious eaters who want contemporary American cooking with Mediterranean leanings.

Must-Try Dishes: Ricotta Dumplings with Mushrooms & Pecorino Sardo, Endive Salad with Walnuts & Anchovies, Bison Tartare with Sunchokes

What makes it special: Michelin-starred, high-impact small plates that helped define modern downtown dining.

View Full Review →

Notable Picks

#2 Blue Ribbon Brasserie

8.8

$$$ SoHo

Vibes: Date Night Magic Late Night Legends Group Dining Gatherings Trendy Table Hotspots

Bruce and Eric Bromberg’s Blue Ribbon Brasserie has anchored SoHo’s late-night dining scene since 1992, pairing a deep raw bar and bone marrow with what many consider some of the city’s definitive fried chicken. High multi-platform ratings and thousands of reviews over three decades support its status as a reliable go-to for chefs, industry regulars, and night-owl diners alike.

Must-Try Dishes: Fried Chicken with Mashed Potatoes & Collard Greens, Beef Marrow with Oxtail Marmalade, Seafood Plateau with Oysters & Shellfish

What makes it special: Iconic late-night SoHo brasserie for fried chicken, marrow, and a serious raw bar.

View Full Review →

#3 The Corner Store

8.5

$$$ SoHo

Vibes: Birthday & Celebration Central Girls Night Out Approved Trendy Table Hotspots Date Night Magic

Opened in 2024 by Catch Hospitality Group, The Corner Store riffs on classic American diner comforts with wagyu French dips, disco steak frites, and playful desserts in a Rockwell-designed room. A months-long waitlist, heavy media coverage, and strong early reviews mark it as one of SoHo’s buzziest new American spots.

Must-Try Dishes: Wagyu French Dip with McOli Sauce, Disco Steak Frites with Peppercorn Aioli, Samoa Cookie Sundae

What makes it special: High-energy, design-forward American spot turning diner classics into spectacle dishes.

View Full Review →

#4 Manuela

8.3

$$$$ SoHo

Vibes: Date Night Magic Brunch Bliss Spots Trendy Table Hotspots Instagram Worthy Wonders

Set inside an airy SoHo art space, Manuela serves seasonal American cooking with a gallery’s sense of composition, from roasted vegetables to polished desserts. Opened in 2024, it’s quickly earned strong notices for refined, produce-driven plates and a room where contemporary artworks share the spotlight with the open kitchen.

Must-Try Dishes: Roasted Cauliflower with Date Vinegar & Almond, Salt-Roasted Sunchokes with Ricotta & Celery, Pavlova with Seasonal Market Fruits

What makes it special: Gallery-like space where seasonal American plates and contemporary art share the stage.

View Full Review →

#5 Fanelli Cafe

8.0

$$$$ SoHo

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Late Night Legends Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Operating on this corner since the 19th century, Fanelli Cafe is one of New York’s oldest bar-restaurants, now serving straightforward pubby American fare to artists, locals, and visitors in a time-worn room. Burgers, chili, and open-faced tuna melts anchor a menu that’s more about atmosphere, value, and history than trend-chasing.

Must-Try Dishes: Fanelli's Burger with Fries, Open-Faced Tuna Melt with Cheddar, Moroccan Lamb Stew

What makes it special: Historic SoHo tavern where burgers, chili, and martinis meet creaky floors and decades of stories.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#6 Wicked Willy's

7.6

$$ Greenwich Village

Vibes: Late Night Legends Sports Bar Central Happy Hour Hotspots Group Dining Gatherings

Wicked Willy’s is a pirate-themed Bleecker Street bar and grill best known for karaoke nights, sports on TV, bottomless brunch, and a long menu of wings, burgers, tacos, and late-night snacks. It’s less about culinary finesse and more about lively energy, big portions, and approachable American bar food that keeps parties fueled until the early hours.

Must-Try Dishes: Wicked Wings with Choice of Sauce, Loaded Nachos with Cheddar, Beans & Jalapeños, Wicked Burger with Candy Bacon & Fries

What makes it special: Rowdy pirate-themed bar for karaoke, game-day screens, and crowd-pleasing American bar food.

View Full Review →