What is the best Bagels restaurant in Sunset Park?

Sunset Bagels Cafe and Grill is our top pick for Bagels restaurants in Sunset Park, scoring 8.4/10. 24/7 neighborhood bagel-and-grill hub with serious volume.

Any insider tips for Sunset Bagels Cafe and Grill?

Order a toasted everything with lox spread and add hash browns on the side for a cheap, filling combo.

What should I order at Sunset Bagels Cafe and Grill?

Sunset Sampler, bacon egg cheese bagel, everything with scallion schmear.

When should I visit Sunset Bagels Cafe and Grill?

Late nights and weekend mornings for freshest bagels and grill.

Who should go to Sunset Bagels Cafe and Grill?

Bagel fans wanting 24/7 breakfast and grill options.

Any insider tips for Metro Bagel & Cafe?

Order a dozen bagels early on weekends if you’re feeding a crowd; they can run low by late morning.

What should I order at Metro Bagel & Cafe?

Everything bagel with lox, bacon-egg-cheese, two-egg platter.

When should I visit Metro Bagel & Cafe?

Morning rush hours for the freshest bagels and turnover.

Who should go to Metro Bagel & Cafe?

Commuters and locals needing a fast, affordable breakfast.

Any insider tips for Panchos Bagel and Deli?

Pair a toasted bagel sandwich with one of their fresh juices to turn a quick bite into a full, still-affordable meal.

What should I order at Panchos Bagel and Deli?

Everything with cream cheese, bacon egg cheese bagel, chicken avocado bagel.

When should I visit Panchos Bagel and Deli?

Breakfast and lunch hours when griddle turnover runs strongest.

Who should go to Panchos Bagel and Deli?

Bagel lovers who also want hearty deli-style options.

Best Bagels Restaurants in Sunset Park (11220)

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Sunset Bagels Cafe and Grill

24/7 neighborhood bagel-and-grill hub with serious volume.

Notable Picks

#1 Sunset Bagels Cafe and Grill

8.4

$ Sunset Park - 5th Avenue Strip

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Late Night Legends Trendy Table Hotspots

Sunset Bagels Cafe and Grill runs 24/7 on 5th Avenue, turning out hand-rolled, boiled bagels alongside a full short-order grill menu. Locals lean on it for anytime bacon-egg-cheese runs, late-night sandwiches, and hefty platters that feel more like diner plates than grab-and-go snacks.

Must-Try Dishes: Everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, Bacon egg and cheese on sesame, Sunset Sampler breakfast platter

What makes it special: 24/7 neighborhood bagel-and-grill hub with serious volume.

View Full Review →

#2 Metro Bagel & Cafe

8.1

$ Sunset Park - 4th Avenue Corridor

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Family Friendly Favorites Quick Bites Champions

Metro Bagel & Cafe sits near the 59th Street hub with a long menu that runs from classic bagel sandwiches to pancakes, salads, and burgers. It functions as an all-purpose breakfast-and-lunch cafe where commuters and neighborhood regulars grab coffee, eggs, and fresh-baked bagels without table-service fuss.

Must-Try Dishes: Everything bagel with lox spread, Bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll or bagel, Two-egg platter with home fries and toast

What makes it special: Early-opening bagel shop focused on hand-rolled bagels and quick breakfast combos.

View Full Review →

#3 Panchos Bagel and Deli

8.0

$ Sunset Park - 4th Avenue Mid

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Quick Bites Champions Hidden Gems Heaven

Panchos Bagel and Deli blends classic New York bagel service with bodega-style hot food, from breakfast sandwiches to burritos and gyros. It’s the kind of corner spot where you can grab a toasted bagel, a pressed sandwich, or a full plate any time the craving hits.

Must-Try Dishes: Everything bagel with cream cheese and tomato, Bacon egg and cheese bagel sandwich, Bagel with grilled chicken and avocado

What makes it special: Bagel-forward deli that also turns out full bodega-style hot plates.

View Full Review →