What is the best Burgers restaurant in Midtown East?

P.J. Clarke's is our top pick for Burgers restaurants in Midtown East, scoring 8.4/10. Historic Midtown saloon serving one of NYC’s most storied burgers.

Any insider tips for P.J. Clarke's ?

Sit at the bar; burgers come faster and service stays sharper.

When should I visit P.J. Clarke's ?

Weeknights for lively bar energy without brutal waits.

Who should go to P.J. Clarke's ?

Burger traditionalists, Midtown workers, and first-time NYC visitors.

Any insider tips for Schnipper's - Midtown East?

Head upstairs for more seating and a slightly calmer feel.

When should I visit Schnipper's - Midtown East?

Early lunch or late afternoon to avoid peak lines.

Who should go to Schnipper's - Midtown East?

Office crowds, families, and burger fans on a budget.

Any insider tips for The Bar Room?

Ask for the skylit back room for a calmer, date-friendly feel.

When should I visit The Bar Room?

After-work happy hour or later evenings for best atmosphere.

Who should go to The Bar Room?

Couples, small groups, and clients who still want burgers.

Best Burgers Restaurants in Midtown East (10022)

Q: What should I order at P.J. Clarke's ?

Cadillac Burger, classic cheeseburger, shoestring onion rings.

Q: What should I order at Schnipper's - Midtown East?

Schnipper's Classic Burger, Texas Burger, Sloppy Joe.

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

P.J. Clarke's

Historic Midtown saloon serving one of NYC’s most storied burgers.

Notable Picks

#1 P.J. Clarke's

8.4

$$ Midtown East

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Business Lunch Power Players Group Dining Gatherings Solo Dining Sanctuaries

A classic 1884 saloon best known for its Cadillac-style burgers, cold martinis, and crowded barroom energy. Locals and office regulars come for reliably juicy patties, thin onion rings, and a slice of old Midtown East that still feels lived-in rather than themed.

Must-Try Dishes: Cadillac Burger, Classic Cheeseburger, Shoestring Onion Rings

What makes it special: Historic Midtown saloon serving one of NYC’s most storied burgers.

View Full Review →

#2 Schnipper's - Midtown East

8.3

$ Midtown East

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Family Friendly Favorites Quick Bites Champions Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Family-run since 2009, this fast-casual counter inside 570 Lex turns out griddled burgers, sloppy joes, and shakes for office workers and families on the move. It’s a volume operation, but execution on the core burgers is consistently better than the food-court setting suggests.

Must-Try Dishes: Schnipper's Classic Burger, Texas Burger, Sloppy Joe

What makes it special: High-volume burgers and sloppy joes that stay surprisingly dialed-in.

View Full Review →

#3 The Bar Room

8.2

$$$ Midtown East

Vibes: Date Night Magic Girls Night Out Approved Happy Hour Hotspots Trendy Table Hotspots

A polished bistro-bar just off Park that treats its house burger with the same care as its cocktails and lobster roll. The Bar Room Burger comes stacked with sharp cheddar, truffle aioli, and proper fries, making it a go-to Midtown East option when you want a burger but not a bare-bones setting.

Must-Try Dishes: The Bar Room Burger, Truffle Fries, Lobster Roll

What makes it special: Cocktail-bar polish with a chef-driven burger and shareable plates.

View Full Review →