Any insider tips for Starbelly?

Request patio shade on warm days.

When should I visit Starbelly?

Right at open on weekends for easy seating

Who should go to Starbelly?

Patio seekers and casual groups

Any insider tips for Orphan Andy's?

Counter seats turn fast—order a milkshake while you wait.

When should I visit Orphan Andy's?

Thu–Sat after 11pm for true late-night energy

Who should go to Orphan Andy's?

Night owls craving classic diner burgers

Any insider tips for Hi Tops?

Bar seats turn fastest—ideal for quick reorders on wing night.

What should I order at Hi Tops?

Buffalo wings, nachos, draft beer

When should I visit Hi Tops?

Weekdays late afternoon for seating and drink deals

Who should go to Hi Tops?

Game-day crews and wing traditionalists

Any insider tips for The Cove on Castro Cafe?

Weekday specials offer strong value.

When should I visit The Cove on Castro Cafe?

Before 10am for a quieter dining room

Who should go to The Cove on Castro Cafe?

Castro locals and visiting families

Best Burgers Restaurants in The Castro (94114)

Q: What should I order at Starbelly?

Benedict, breakfast pizza, cinnamon French toast

4 hand-picked restaurants, AI-analyzed and critic-validated

Notable Picks

#1 Starbelly

8.1

$$ The Castro

Vibes: Brunch Bliss Spots Outdoor Dining Oasis Group Dining Gatherings Trendy Table Hotspots

Sunny neighborhood California kitchen with a popular patio and balanced brunch menu. Efficient service and a mix of comfort and lighter plates keep it in regular rotation.

Must-Try Dishes: Eggs Benedict, Breakfast pizza, Cinnamon French toast

What makes it special: Patio-friendly brunch with California flavors and balanced plates.

View Full Review →

#2 Orphan Andy's

8.1

$ The Castro

Vibes: Late Night Legends Comfort Food Classics Family Friendly Favorites Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Retro Castro diner turning out griddled burgers, patty melts, and fries alongside breakfast-all-day comforts. Open late (24 hours on weekends) and beloved since the late ’70s, it’s the reliable post-bar burger fix with no pretense.

Must-Try Dishes: Ortega Burger, Patty Melt, Chili Burger

What makes it special: Long-running Castro diner serving late-night burgers and breakfasts.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 Hi Tops

7.9

$$ The Castro

Vibes: Sports Bar Central Happy Hour Hotspots Group Dining Gatherings Quick Bites Champions

Castro’s OG gay sports bar (since 2012) with TVs everywhere, lively crowds, and wing nights that dovetail with drink deals. Wings lean classic—think buffalo—with speedy bar service ideal for game-time bites.

Must-Try Dishes: Buffalo wings, Loaded nachos, Fried chicken sandwich

What makes it special: Wing specials during happy hour in a true sports-bar setting.

View Full Review →

#4 The Cove on Castro Cafe

7.6

$ The Castro

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Family Friendly Favorites Group Dining Gatherings Brunch Bliss Spots

Long-running Castro landmark serving classic cheeseburgers, melts, and diner comforts alongside soups baked daily. It’s a mellow, affordable sit-down option when you want a straightforward griddled burger.

Must-Try Dishes: Belgian waffle, Greek omelet, Breakfast platter

What makes it special: Neighborhood fixture with old-school hospitality and broad brunch selection.

View Full Review →