What is the best Burritos restaurant in Sunset Park?

Tacos Matamoros is our top pick for Burritos restaurants in Sunset Park, scoring 8.7/10. High-volume, cash-only Mexican diner that anchors Sunset Park’s taco scene.

Any insider tips for Tacos Matamoros?

It’s cash-only, so bring bills and ask for the off-menu mole plates.

What should I order at Tacos Matamoros?

Tacos al pastor, mole poblano tamales, carne asada plates.

When should I visit Tacos Matamoros?

Evenings before peak rush or late-night for full energy.

Who should go to Tacos Matamoros?

Groups and locals craving classic tacos and plates.

Any insider tips for Ricos Tacos?

Order a torta and a taco plate to split; portions run large and filling.

What should I order at Ricos Tacos?

Pierna adobada tacos, chilaquiles rojos, a loaded torta to share.

When should I visit Ricos Tacos?

Late nights or weekend afternoons for peak energy and turnover.

Who should go to Ricos Tacos?

Hungry night owls and locals who want hearty Mexican classics.

Any insider tips for Cinco de Mayo?

If you like crunch, add fries inside the burrito and ask for salsas on the side to control the sauciness.

What should I order at Cinco de Mayo?

California Burrito, Fish Burrito, Cinco de Mayo Plate with extra guacamole.

When should I visit Cinco de Mayo?

Evenings and weekends when the kitchen is turning out birria nonstop.

Who should go to Cinco de Mayo?

Burrito lovers who want loaded, sauce-heavy wraps and bowls.

Any insider tips for Tacos Los Poblanos #3?

Build a mixed taco order and ask for extra salsa verde on the side.

What should I order at Tacos Los Poblanos #3?

Tacos al pastor, a mix of carnitas tacos, and a quesillo torta.

When should I visit Tacos Los Poblanos #3?

Early evening when the grill is busiest and tacos are freshest.

Who should go to Tacos Los Poblanos #3?

Taco purists looking for quick, affordable street-style options.

Any insider tips for Isabella's Mexican Restaurant?

Delivery is fast—use it when you want hot food without leaving home.

When should I visit Isabella's Mexican Restaurant?

Mornings for breakfast plates, late evenings for delivery cravings.

Who should go to Isabella's Mexican Restaurant?

Locals wanting dependable, no-frills Mexican comfort food.

Best Burritos Restaurants in Sunset Park (11220)

5 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Tacos Matamoros

High-volume, cash-only Mexican diner that anchors Sunset Park’s taco scene.

Notable Picks

#1 Tacos Matamoros

8.7

Sunset Park – 51st Street Corridor

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Hidden Gems Heaven

Tacos Matamoros is a cash-only Sunset Park institution where a sprawling menu of tacos, tamales, and mole plates anchors one of the neighborhood’s most consistently busy dining rooms. With thousands of reviews across platforms and regular love from local food writers, it’s the go-to spot for generous plates, late hours, and a true Fifth Avenue Mexican diner feel.

Must-Try Dishes: Tacos al pastor on double-layer tortillas, Mole poblano tamales, Huevos con chorizo breakfast plates

What makes it special: High-volume, cash-only Mexican diner that anchors Sunset Park’s taco scene.

View Full Review →

#2 Ricos Tacos

8.4

$$ Sunset Park - 51st Street Corridor

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Late Night Legends Quick Bites Champions Group Dining Gatherings

Ricos Tacos is a 51st Street institution, running long hours for tacos, tortas, and full plates that fuel neighborhood regulars day and night. The menu leans hearty, with griddled meats, chilaquiles, and overstuffed sandwiches served in a no-frills dining room.

Must-Try Dishes: Tacos de pierna adobada, Chilaquiles rojos con cecina, Pierna adobada torta

What makes it special: High-volume, late-hours Mexican spot where tacos share billing with big plates and tortas.

View Full Review →

#3 Cinco de Mayo

8.2

$$ Sunset Park - 45th Street

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Group Dining Gatherings Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Trendy Table Hotspots

Cinco de Mayo, operated with Eva’s, leans into burritos as part of a broader menu of birria tacos, salads, and combo plates. Their California-style burrito and wrap-or-bowl format appeal to diners who want saucy, fully loaded bundles with fries, guacamole, and melted cheese inside.

Must-Try Dishes: California Burrito, Fish Burrito, Cinco de Mayo Plate with Burrito Wrap

What makes it special: Menu with California-style burritos and birria plates that lets you choose between wraps and bowls loaded with fries, guacamole, and melted cheese.

View Full Review →

#4 Tacos Los Poblanos #3

8.0

$ Sunset Park - 5th Avenue Hub

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Quick Bites Champions Hidden Gems Heaven

Tacos Los Poblanos #3 is a compact 5th Avenue storefront focused on classic street-style tacos at wallet-friendly prices. Freshly griddled tortillas, a focused menu, and late-afternoon-to-late-night hours make it a reliable stop for quick taco runs.

Must-Try Dishes: Taco al pastor, Carnitas tacos, Quesillo torta

What makes it special: Tight, taco-focused shop where al pastor and other fillings stay front and center.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#5 Isabella's Mexican Restaurant

7.6

$ Sunset Park - 4th Avenue Corridor

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Comfort Food Classics Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Isabela's Mexican Restaurant is a longtime Fourth Avenue spot serving breakfast plates, tortas, burritos, and nachos to neighborhood regulars. Reviews highlight quick delivery, generous portions, and a casual room that works as well for a simple morning plate as for a late-night burrito.

Must-Try Dishes: Torta milanesa de pollo, Chicken burrito, Nachos locos with steak

What makes it special: Everyday neighborhood spot for affordable tortas, burritos, and breakfast plates.

View Full Review →