What is the best Burritos restaurant in Upper West Side?

Burrito Supreme is our top pick for Burritos restaurants in Upper West Side, scoring 8.7/10. Authentic fillings with bold flavors in every bite.

Any insider tips for Burrito Supreme?

Try their hot salsa for an extra kick.

When should I visit Burrito Supreme?

Weekdays for quick service during lunch.

Who should go to Burrito Supreme?

Burrito lovers seeking quick, hearty meals.

Any insider tips for The Burrito Bar?

Check out their seasonal burrito specials.

When should I visit The Burrito Bar?

Weekdays for a quick, tasty lunch.

Who should go to The Burrito Bar?

Those looking to build their perfect burrito.

Any insider tips for Burrito King?

Great for takeout if you're on the go.

Who should go to Burrito King?

Budget-conscious burrito lovers.

Best Burritos Restaurants in Upper West Side (10023)

Q: What should I order at Burrito Supreme?

Supreme Burrito, Chili Lime Burrito, Vegetarian Wrap.

Q: What should I order at The Burrito Bar?

Custom Burrito, Chipotle Chicken Burrito, Veggie Burrito.

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: December 2025

Save

Our Top Pick

Burrito Supreme

Authentic fillings with bold flavors in every bite.

Notable Picks

#1 Burrito Supreme

8.7

$$ Flatiron

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics

A local favorite serving hearty and flavorful burritos with bold fillings and authentic ingredients.

Must-Try Dishes: Supreme Burrito, Chili Lime Burrito, Vegetarian Wrap

What Makes it Special: Authentic fillings with bold flavors in every bite.

View Full Review →

#2 The Burrito Bar

8.5

$$ Upper West Side-Lincoln Square

Vibes: Trendy Table Hotspots Quick Bites Champions Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance

This trendy spot focuses on customization, offering a wide variety of toppings and burrito styles for the discerning eater.

Must-Try Dishes: Custom Burrito, Chipotle Chicken Burrito, Veggie Burrito

What Makes it Special: Endless burrito customization options.

View Full Review →

#3 Burrito King

8.3

$ Upper West Side-Lincoln Square

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Quick Bites Champions

A cozy spot for budget-friendly burritos with all the traditional fillings and flavors.

Must-Try Dishes: Classic Beef Burrito, Chicken Burrito, Fish Tacos

What Makes it Special: Affordable, no-frills burritos with satisfying portions.

View Full Review →