Any insider tips for Pirro’s Pizzeria?

Call ahead—counter pick-up is faster than third-party apps.

What should I order at Pirro’s Pizzeria?

Sicilian square, combo pie, garlic bread

When should I visit Pirro’s Pizzeria?

Early evening before peak delivery rush

Who should go to Pirro’s Pizzeria?

Families and classic pizza loyalists

Any insider tips for Golden Boy Pizza (Sunset)?

Ask for a corner slice for extra crusty edges.

When should I visit Golden Boy Pizza (Sunset)?

Midday or early evening to avoid lines

Who should go to Golden Boy Pizza (Sunset)?

Slice hunters and quick takeout seekers

Any insider tips for Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)?

Ask for extra-crisp reheat on slices after midnight.

What should I order at Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)?

Chick-O-Oni slice, wings, garlic knots

When should I visit Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)?

After 11pm when most Sunset kitchens close

Who should go to Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)?

Night owls needing quick, filling pizza

Any insider tips for North Beach Pizza (Taraval)?

Half-bake the Sicilian pie to finish at home for crispier edges.

What should I order at North Beach Pizza (Taraval)?

Meat lasagna; Sicilian thick-crust; garlic bread

When should I visit North Beach Pizza (Taraval)?

Weeknights after 7pm for shorter waits

Who should go to North Beach Pizza (Taraval)?

Families and casual pizza-and-pasta crowds

Any insider tips for Brothers Pizza?

Call ahead—ribs can sell out on busy weekends.

What should I order at Brothers Pizza?

BBQ pork ribs; side salad; a slice to share

When should I visit Brothers Pizza?

Early evenings before the dinner rush

Who should go to Brothers Pizza?

Casual groups with mixed cravings

Any insider tips for Eagle Pizzeria?

Call in for pickup to skip third-party app queues.

What should I order at Eagle Pizzeria?

Meat lasagna; ravioli; garlic bread

When should I visit Eagle Pizzeria?

Late afternoon to beat dinner rush

Who should go to Eagle Pizzeria?

Budget pasta fans and takeout regulars

Best Cheap Eats Pizza Restaurants in The Outer Sunset (94116)

6 hand-picked restaurants, AI-analyzed and critic-validated

Notable Picks

#1 Pirro’s Pizzeria

8.4

$$ Outer Parkside

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Quick Bites Champions

Long-running Taraval standby (since 1954) turning out hand-spun pies and thick Sicilian squares in a roomy, old-school dining room. Reliable for family dinners with hearty portions and late-ish weekend hours.

Must-Try Dishes: Sicilian Square Pizza, Pirro’s Special Combo Pie, Garlic Bread

What makes it special: Decades-strong pizzeria with hand-spun pies and Sicilian trays.

View Full Review →

#2 Golden Boy Pizza (Sunset)

8.3

$ Parkside

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Family Friendly Favorites Hidden Gems Heaven Trendy Table Hotspots

Square, Sicilian-style slices served from a takeout window with quick turnover and consistent bakes. Locals stop for pepperoni or clam squares that are crisp-edged, saucy, and budget-friendly.

Must-Try Dishes: Garlic Clam Slice, Combo Slice, Pepperoni Slice

What makes it special: SF-famous square slices with distinctive focaccia-style crust.

View Full Review →

#3 Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)

8.1

$ Parkside

Vibes: Late Night Legends Quick Bites Champions Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Counter-service slice shop popular after games and late shifts, with fast turnarounds and a deep specialty list. Consistent for quick slices, wings, and hearty combos into the night.

Must-Try Dishes: Chick-O-Oni (pesto chicken + pepperoni, white sauce), Pepperoni & jalapeño slice, Garlic knots

What makes it special: Open very late with fast, reliable slices.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#4 North Beach Pizza (Taraval)

7.9

$$$ Outer Parkside

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Group Dining Gatherings Comfort Food Classics Quick Bites Champions

Casual sit-down spot for hefty pies, calzones, and pastas with steady late-evening service most nights. Go for straightforward combos and dependable slices without the wait.

Must-Try Dishes: Meat Lasagna, Sicilian Thick-Crust Pizza, Spaghetti with Meatballs

What makes it special: Classic, saucy meat lasagna from a long-running SF pizza outfit.

View Full Review →

#5 Brothers Pizza

7.8

$ Outer Parkside

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings

Neighborhood counter spot known for Indian-influenced specialty pies alongside straightforward classics. A practical, low-cost option for quick dinners on the far west side.

Must-Try Dishes: BBQ Pork Ribs, BBQ Chicken, Garlic Bread

What makes it special: Unexpected but satisfying ribs from a long-running Taraval pizza shop.

View Full Review →

#6 Eagle Pizzeria

7.7

$$ Parkside

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Family Friendly Favorites

Old-school takeout and delivery operation with customizable pies and a deep specials board, including vegan variants. Portions are generous and pricing stays reasonable for shareable dinners.

Must-Try Dishes: Classic Meat Lasagna, Ravioli (Beef or Cheese), Chicken Parmigiana

What makes it special: Counter-service lasagna at true neighborhood-friendly prices.

View Full Review →