Best Cheap Pizza Restaurants in Lincoln Park (60614)
4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: January 2026
Our Top Pick
Pequod's Pizza
Signature caramelized-crust pan pizzas that define Chicago deep-dish for many.
Notable Picks
8.9
Pequod’s is the Lincoln Park deep-dish institution where caramelized-crust pan pizzas, heavy on sausage and cheese, stay relatively affordable for how much food you get. Lines, waits, and a no-frills barroom feel are part of the deal, but high-volume lunch specials and shareable pans keep it in regular rotation for groups looking for classic Chicago pizza without white-tablecloth pricing.
Must-Try Dishes:
Sausage pan pizza with caramelized crust, Pepperoni deep-dish pan pizza, Pequod's house salad
What makes it special: Signature caramelized-crust pan pizzas that define Chicago deep-dish for many.
#2
Homeslice
8.4
Homeslice is a high-energy pizza-and-patio hangout near DePaul, built around playful toppings, cocktails, and a crowd that treats it as a standing meetup spot. With a big all-season patio and shareable pies, it functions more as a social hub that happens to serve solid, crowd-pleasing pizza.
Must-Try Dishes:
The 312 pizza, Clay Bacon pizza, Goat cheese marinara with bread
What makes it special: High-energy pizza bar with creative pies, a big patio, and playful service.
8.2
Bacino’s of Lincoln Park is a long-running stuffed-pizza parlor known for spinach-heavy pies, thin crust, and classic red-sauce comfort at moderate prices. With decades of history and strong multi-platform ratings, it’s the move when you want a hearty Chicago-style stuffed pizza sit-down experience without tourist-trap premiums.
Must-Try Dishes:
Spinach Supreme Stuffed Pizza, Bacino's Special thin crust pizza, Very Very Vegetarian thin crust pizza
What makes it special: Since 1978, a stuffed-and-thin joint best known for spinach-forward, 'heart-healthy' pies.
Worthy Picks
The Slice Hut at Neon Gardens is a newer NYC-style slice shop inside a retro arcade bar, serving oversized slices, creative toppings, and gelato. Prices skew higher per slice than old-school counters, but the size, quality of toppings, and quick service make it a solid value for a casual, entertainment-first night out.
Must-Try Dishes:
Pepperoni slice, Sicilian Carne square slice, Build Your Own whole pie
What makes it special: NYC-style slices and Sicilian squares served inside a neon-soaked arcade bar.