What is the best Pizza restaurant in Lower East Side?

Jonny's Pizza is our top pick for Pizza restaurants in Lower East Side, scoring 8.3/10. Late‑night, vodka‑sauce pepperoni slices that win cult favorite status.

Any insider tips for Jonny's Pizza?

Order through delivery or go early Friday/Saturday to avoid long lines.

What should I order at Jonny's Pizza?

Vodka pepperoni slice, hot‑honey slice, cheese slice.

When should I visit Jonny's Pizza?

After midnight until ~3:30 AM weekends.

Who should go to Jonny's Pizza?

Night owls craving a slice after hours.

Any insider tips for Square Pizza NYC?

They offer round and square pies — square gives you caramelized crust edges worth it.

What should I order at Square Pizza NYC?

Square pepperoni, Margherita, buffalo chicken square pie.

When should I visit Square Pizza NYC?

Lunch or early dinner for freshest crust.

Who should go to Square Pizza NYC?

Groups wanting a filling pie to share.

Any insider tips for Pizza Loves Sauce?

Drop in for a quick slice — portions are modest but price‑point makes it value.

What should I order at Pizza Loves Sauce?

Cheese slice, pepperoni slice, Margherita slice.

When should I visit Pizza Loves Sauce?

Any time during open hours — convenient and easy.

Who should go to Pizza Loves Sauce?

Casual diners or people grabbing a quick meal.

Best Cheap Pizza Restaurants in Lower East Side (10002)

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Jonny's Pizza

Late‑night, vodka‑sauce pepperoni slices that win cult favorite status.

Notable Picks

#1 Jonny's Pizza

8.3

$$ Lower East Side

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Late Night Legends Quick Bites Champions Group Dining Gatherings

Thin‑crust NYC‑style pizza with inventive options like vodka‑sauce pepperoni and hot honey, popular for late‑night slices and delivery. Locals and visitors stop in for reliably good pies and a simple, unpretentious vibe.

Must-Try Dishes: Vodka pepperoni pizza, Hot‑honey pepperoni slice, Classic cheese slice

What makes it special: Late‑night, vodka‑sauce pepperoni slices that win cult favorite status.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#2 Square Pizza NYC

7.8

$$ Lower East Side

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Quick Bites Champions Group Dining Gatherings

Detroit‑style square pizzas in a takeout‑friendly setup — thick, airy crust with cheese‑caramelized edges offers a different than usual slice experience in the neighborhood. Good value for a heavier pie rather than a quick foldable slice.

Must-Try Dishes: Square pepperoni pizza, Margherita round pizza, Buffalo chicken square pizza

What makes it special: Detroit‑style square pies uncommon for this ZIP, thick crust and hearty portions.

View Full Review →

#3 Pizza Loves Sauce

7.6

$$ Lower East Side

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Late Night Legends Comfort Food Classics

A no‑frills slice shop with flexible options and a variety of toppings, good for a casual, budget‑friendly pie or slice. Known among locals for its convenience and simple, solid pizza by the slice or pie.

Must-Try Dishes: Cheese slice, Classic pepperoni slice, Margherita slice

What makes it special: Accessible slice‑by‑slice pizza at reasonable prices and relaxed pace.

View Full Review →