Best Cheap Pizza Restaurants in Sunset Park (11220)
5 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: July 2026
Our Top Pick
Luigi's Pizza
Old-school neighborhood slice shop with a deep menu and long local following.
Notable Picks
8.4
Vibes:
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Comfort Food Classics
Quick Bites Champions
Family Friendly Favorites
Luigi's Pizza is a classic Sunset Park slice shop known for thin-crust New York pies, Sicilian squares, and a steady flow of neighborhood regulars. A long menu of pies, pastas, and heroes makes it as useful for quick slices as for casual family dinners.
Must-Try Dishes:
Cheese pizza, Grandma pie, Buffalo chicken pizza
What Makes it Special: Old-school neighborhood slice shop with a deep menu and long local following.
8.1
Cafe 58 Pizzeria & Grill blends a neighborhood cafe feel with a full pizza and grill menu, serving breakfast, brunch, and Sicilian-style pies from morning through late afternoon. It’s a flexible all-day hangout where locals can grab coffee, slices, wings, and sandwiches under one roof.
Must-Try Dishes:
Cheese pizza, Buffalo chicken pizza, Buffalo wings
What Makes it Special: Daytime cafe-pizzeria hybrid offering coffee, brunch plates, and serious pies.
Worthy Picks
7.8
Vibes:
Family Friendly Favorites
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Comfort Food Classics
Solo Dining Sanctuaries
A Sunset Park institution known for its signature square slices and taco pizza. This sit-down pizza parlor offers an extensive menu of Italian-American favorites from hot pasta platters to seafood dishes. The Sophia Loren pizza with fresh mozzarella and tomato is a local secret.
Must-Try Dishes:
Taco Pizza Slice, Square Slice, Sophia Loren Pizza
What Makes it Special: Famous square slices and creative specialty pizzas like the taco slice
#4
Xochil Pizza
7.6
Xochil Pizza sits on the lower 5th Avenue corridor and mixes New York slices with a menu of Mexican snacks, wings, and aguas frescas. It’s a casual choice when you want a couple of slices plus something different, like a pepperoni roll or a side of wings, without spending much.
Must-Try Dishes:
Regular cheese slice, Sicilian slice, Pepperoni roll
What Makes it Special: Slice shop that layers in Mexican snacks and aguas frescas.
Vibes:
Comfort Food Classics
Family Friendly Favorites
Group Dining Gatherings
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Puerto Rico Restaurant Pizzeria anchors the mid-50s stretch of 5th Avenue with a menu that pairs classic pies and slices with affordable Puerto Rican plates. Regulars treat it as an all-purpose neighborhood canteen where you can grab a couple of slices or sit for a hearty, rice-and-meat meal without leaving the cheap-eats bracket.
Must-Try Dishes:
Regular cheese slice, Pepperoni slice, House special pizza
What Makes it Special: Hybrid Puerto Rican restaurant and pizzeria that keeps prices low.