Best Date Night Italian Restaurants in Chelsea (10011)
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: January 2026
Our Top Pick
Da Andrea - Chelsea
Seasonal menu and rustic Italian dishes in a cozy setting.
Notable Picks
8.7
This neighborhood Italian spot offers a cozy ambiance with a seasonal menu that highlights fresh ingredients and classic Italian flavors. Locals love their flavorful pasta and wine selection.
Must-Try Dishes:
Pasta alla Vodka, Osso Buco, Tiramisu
What makes it special: Seasonal menu and rustic Italian dishes in a cozy setting.
8.3
A longtime Chelsea staple delivering wood‑fired pizzas and homemade pasta, with a warm, familiar vibe ideal for relaxed date nights. Regulars highlight its gnocchi and classic tiramisu as reliably satisfying. The welcoming service and cozy interior make it popular for both casual dinners and celebrations.
Must-Try Dishes:
Wood‑fired brick oven pizza, Homemade pasta, Tiramisu dessert
What makes it special: Wood‑fired pizzas and consistent neighborhood‑style Italian comfort.
#3
Zia Maria
8.1
Family‑owned pasta and pizza spot offering fresh-made pasta and casual drinks — a relaxed pick for a laid‑back date night. The bar adds flexibility for a pre‑ or post‑dinner cocktail, and sharing a custom pizza adds to the easygoing vibe. Portions and flavors consistently satisfy after multiple visits.
Must-Try Dishes:
Neapolitan‑style pizza, Homemade fresh pasta, Antipasti platter
What makes it special: Wood‑fired pizzas and handmade pastas near the High Line.