What is the best Italian restaurant in Sunset Park?

Luigi's Pizza is our top pick for Italian restaurants in Sunset Park, scoring 8.4/10. Old-school neighborhood slice shop with a deep menu and long local following.

Any insider tips for Luigi's Pizza ?

Pair a pie with a hero or pasta from the specials for better value.

What should I order at Luigi's Pizza ?

Cheese slice, grandma pie, Buffalo chicken pizza

When should I visit Luigi's Pizza ?

Lunch or early dinner before peak delivery rush

Who should go to Luigi's Pizza ?

Slice lovers and families wanting casual Italian comfort

Any insider tips for Dominick's Pizzeria?

They still have slushies - perfect childhood nostalgia pairing with pizza

What should I order at Dominick's Pizzeria?

Pepperoni slice, homemade lasagna, zeppoles

When should I visit Dominick's Pizzeria?

Lunch or early dinner for fresh slices

Who should go to Dominick's Pizzeria?

Pizza purists and families seeking value

Any insider tips for Original Pizza?

Second generation family still uses original recipes from 1964

What should I order at Original Pizza?

Plain cheese slice, Sicilian slice, garlic knots

When should I visit Original Pizza?

Lunch for hot fresh slices straight from oven

Who should go to Original Pizza?

Classic NY pizza enthusiasts and nostalgic locals

Any insider tips for Royal Kings Pizza?

The Philly cheesesteak sandwiches rival the pizza in popularity

What should I order at Royal Kings Pizza?

Square slice, taco pizza, vegetable slice

When should I visit Royal Kings Pizza?

Any time - open late until 11pm daily

Who should go to Royal Kings Pizza?

Adventurous pizza lovers and families

Best Date Night Italian Restaurants in Sunset Park (11220)

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Luigi's Pizza

Old-school neighborhood slice shop with a deep menu and long local following.

Notable Picks

#1 Luigi's Pizza

8.4

$ Sunset Park – 5th Avenue Corridor

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Quick Bites Champions Family Friendly Favorites

Luigi's Pizza On 47th is a long-running, family-owned pizzeria where New York–style pies, baked dishes, and hearty pastas turn a simple slice joint into a relaxed, low-key date option. The cozy dining room, friendly staff, and decades-long local following make it a comfortable spot for couples who care more about great pizza than polished decor.

Must-Try Dishes: Cheese pizza, Grandma pie, Buffalo chicken pizza

What makes it special: Old-school neighborhood slice shop with a deep menu and long local following.

View Full Review →

#2 Dominick's Pizzeria

8.2

$$ Sunset Park – 8th Avenue Corridor

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Comfort Food Classics

Dominick's Pizzeria on 8th Avenue is a long-time Sunset Park staple where big pies, Italian-American plates, and glasses of beer or wine make casual date nights feel easy. Couples use it as a meet-in-the-middle spot when one person wants classic slices and the other wants a fuller sit-down dinner.

Must-Try Dishes: Pepperoni Slice, Lasagna, Pepperoni Roll

What makes it special: 25+ years of consistent Brooklyn-style pizza with homemade Italian dishes

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 Original Pizza

7.9

$$$ Bay Ridge Border – 4th Avenue Corridor

Vibes: Hidden Gems Heaven Quick Bites Champions Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Original Pizza on 4th Avenue straddles the Bay Ridge–Sunset Park border as a sit-down pizzeria where fresh-mozzarella pies and square slices anchor simple, shared meals. It works best for low-key dates when you want to talk over solid pizza rather than dress up for a long, formal dinner.

Must-Try Dishes: Cheese Slice, Sicilian Slice, Margherita Pizza

What makes it special: 60 years of unchanged family recipes with old-world Italian techniques

View Full Review →

#4 Royal Kings Pizza

7.6

$ Sunset Park – 5th Avenue Corridor

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Royal Kings Pizza on 5th Avenue is a busy Sunset Park spot where specialty pies, taco pizza, and other comfort dishes fuel casual, budget-friendly dates. The bright room, background music, and long menu of pizza and Italian-style plates make it an easy choice when you want variety without spending much.

Must-Try Dishes: Taco Pizza Slice, Square Slice, Sophia Loren Pizza

What makes it special: Famous square slices and creative specialty pizzas like the taco slice

View Full Review →