Any insider tips for Palma?

Request the garden or carriage house when booking—those spaces define the Palma experience.

What should I order at Palma?

Arancini, ravioli cacio e pepe, lobster spaghetti.

When should I visit Palma?

Evenings in garden season; weekend brunch for softer crowds.

Who should go to Palma?

Couples, bridal parties, and groups planning celebratory dinners.

Any insider tips for Rafele Ristorante?

Basement seating is often used for bigger groups—mention preference for main-floor or quieter tables when reserving.

What should I order at Rafele Ristorante?

Arancini, tonnarelli cacio e pepe, tagliolini ai funghi.

When should I visit Rafele Ristorante?

Prime dinner hours for energy; early evenings for quieter tables.

Who should go to Rafele Ristorante?

Families and groups wanting classic Italian with room to spread out.

Any insider tips for Numero 28 Pizzeria?

Order one large pie for the table, then add a half-carafe of house wine for adults.

What should I order at Numero 28 Pizzeria?

Margherita pie, Giulietta pie, tagliatelle al ragù.

When should I visit Numero 28 Pizzeria?

Early evening before the small room fully packs up.

Who should go to Numero 28 Pizzeria?

Families wanting a casual sit-down pizza night.

Best Date Night Italian Restaurants in West Village (10014)

Q: What is the best Italian restaurant in West Village?

Palma is our top pick for Italian restaurants in West Village, scoring 8.6/10. A long-running, organic-focused Italian spot with a flower-filled garden and carriage house that feel transported from the countryside.

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Palma

A long-running, organic-focused Italian spot with a flower-filled garden and carriage house that feel transported from the countryside.

Notable Picks

#1 Palma

8.6

$$$ Greenwich Village

Vibes: Date Night Magic Outdoor Dining Oasis Group Dining Gatherings Instagram Worthy Wonders

Family-run since 2001, Palma pairs organic, family-recipe Italian cooking with one of the neighborhood’s most romantic garden settings. Large platters, housemade pastas, and a 200-year-old carriage house make it a go-to for celebrations and intimate dinners alike.

Must-Try Dishes: Ravioli cacio e pepe, Lobster spaghetti in tomato sauce, Fettuccine ai funghi

What makes it special: A long-running, organic-focused Italian spot with a flower-filled garden and carriage house that feel transported from the countryside.

View Full Review →

#2 Rafele Ristorante

8.3

$$$ Greenwich Village

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Family Friendly Favorites

Chef Raffaele Ronca’s Rafele brings Neapolitan-influenced cooking, pizzas, and housemade pastas to a roomy West Village space set up for both dates and groups. Strong multi-year review volume and continued local press keep it in the conversation for classic sit-down Italian in the neighborhood.

Must-Try Dishes: Tonnarelli cacio e pepe, Tagliolini ai funghi, Gnocchi fritto with prosciutto

What makes it special: A chef-driven Neapolitan trattoria with space for larger parties and a menu that balances pizzas, pastas, and rustic mains.

View Full Review →

#3 Numero 28 Pizzeria

8.1

$$$ West Village

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Quick Bites Champions

Wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas in a lively, family-friendly space offering a welcoming atmosphere for relaxed, shared meals.

Must-Try Dishes: Margherita pizza, Giulietta pizza, Tagliatelle al ragù

What makes it special: Wood-fired, family-sized Neapolitan pies with a relaxed, kid-tolerant dining room.

View Full Review →