What is the best Steakhouse restaurant in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn?

Gage & Tollner is our top pick for Steakhouse restaurants in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn, scoring 8.8/10. Historic Michelin-recognized chop house marrying landmark atmosphere with serious steaks.

Any insider tips for Gage & Tollner?

Book early and ask for a table in the main landmarked dining room.

What should I order at Gage & Tollner?

Oysters, New York strip or ribeye, Baked Alaska.

When should I visit Gage & Tollner?

Prime dinner hours or weekend lunch when the room buzzes.

Who should go to Gage & Tollner?

Special-occasion diners who love classic New York steakhouse style.

Any insider tips for Libertador Steakhouse - Brooklyn?

Share a mixed grill and supplement with sides instead of ordering solo steaks.

What should I order at Libertador Steakhouse - Brooklyn?

Skirt steak with chimichurri, empanadas, mixed grill to share.

When should I visit Libertador Steakhouse - Brooklyn?

Weekends or early evenings when the room feels lively.

Who should go to Libertador Steakhouse - Brooklyn?

Groups or couples wanting hearty steaks without formality.

Any insider tips for Carne by Allora?

Start with a martini at the bar and split the bistecca family-style.

What should I order at Carne by Allora?

Bistecca alla Fiorentina, osso buco, pork chop scarpariello.

When should I visit Carne by Allora?

Dinner hours when the bar and dining room feel energized.

Who should go to Carne by Allora?

Steak and pasta fans planning polished hotel-adjacent dinners.

Best Date Night Steakhouse Restaurants in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn (11201)

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Gage & Tollner

Historic Michelin-recognized chop house marrying landmark atmosphere with serious steaks.

Notable Picks

#1 Gage & Tollner

8.8

$$$$ Downtown Brooklyn

Vibes: Date Night Magic Luxury Dining Elite Birthday & Celebration Central Trendy Table Hotspots

A restored 19th-century chophouse with a Michelin-listed steakhouse menu, Gage & Tollner trades in towering seafood platters, big steaks, and classic cocktails under glowing chandeliers. It’s one of Downtown Brooklyn’s most atmospheric rooms for a dressed-up date, especially if you linger over dessert or head upstairs to the Sunken Harbor Club afterward.

Must-Try Dishes: New York strip steak, Dry-aged ribeye, Baked Alaska

What makes it special: Historic Michelin-recognized chop house marrying landmark atmosphere with serious steaks.

View Full Review →

#2 Libertador Steakhouse - Brooklyn

8.1

$$ Cobble Hill

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Birthday & Celebration Central Family Friendly Favorites

Libertador is a cozy Argentine steakhouse just off the brownstones of Cobble Hill, where smoky grilled meats, empanadas, and Malbec anchor the menu. It’s more relaxed and affordable than the white-tablecloth spots, making it a strong option for low-key steak dates or mixed steak-and-wine nights with friends.

Must-Try Dishes: Prime skirt steak (entraña) with chimichurri, New York strip steak, Mixed grill for two

What makes it special: Casual Argentine steakhouse with generous portions and grilled meats at approachable prices.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 Carne by Allora

7.9

$$$ Boerum Hill

Vibes: Luxury Dining Elite Date Night Magic Girls Night Out Approved Trendy Table Hotspots

Tucked into the Hilton near Boerum Hill, Carne by Allora functions as an Italian-leaning steakhouse where bistecca alla Fiorentina, ribeye, and rich pastas share space with a serious cocktail list. The room leans polished but not stiff, suiting couples who want a modern-feeling date night with both steak and Italian comfort on the table.

Must-Try Dishes: Bistecca alla Fiorentina, Osso buco with saffron risotto, Pork chop scarpariello

What makes it special: Italian steakhouse where large-format bistecca and red-sauce comforts share the spotlight.

View Full Review →