Best Date Night Steakhouse Restaurants in Chelsea (10011)
2 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: January 2026
Our Top Pick
Old Homestead Steakhouse
Old‑school Manhattan steakhouse serving classic cuts consistently.
Notable Picks
8.8
A historic New York institution serving massive USDA‑prime steaks in a classic brick‑and‑booth dining room — ideal for a traditional steakhouse date night. Portions are generous and the heritage of the place adds a sense of gravitas and occasion. Many locals and visitors return for the thick cuts and old‑school charm.
Must-Try Dishes:
Porterhouse Steak, Lamb Chop, Creamed Spinach
What makes it special: Old‑school Manhattan steakhouse serving classic cuts consistently.
8.5
An ambient, music‑infused steakhouse mixing well‑executed steaks with a lively soundtrack and cocktail‑forward energy — good for a modern, slightly less formal date night. The combination of well‑cooked steaks, warm service, and vinyl‑record soundtrack gives a playful, contemporary edge. Patrons often highlight its balance of quality and atmosphere without the pretension of old‑school chophouses.
Must-Try Dishes:
38 oz Dry‑Aged Porterhouse for Two, Maryland‑Style Crab Cake, Shoestring Fries
What makes it special: Vinyl‑record soundtrack + dry‑aged steaks and seafood.