Best Date Night Steakhouse Restaurants in Midtown Manhattan (10019)
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: January 2026
Our Top Pick
Quality Meats
Butcher‑driven menu and creative side dishes elevate traditional steakhouse fare.
Notable Picks
8.5
A modern, butcher‑inspired steakhouse offering premium cuts and inventive sides — a sleek spot for a refined yet unpretentious date night. Known for dry‑aged steaks and a menu that balances classic chops with creative touches.
Must-Try Dishes:
Bone‑in ribeye, House‑cured bacon, Roasted bone marrow
What makes it special: Butcher‑driven menu and creative side dishes elevate traditional steakhouse fare.
8.2
A storied Midtown steakhouse with vintage charm, known for coal‑grilled dry‑aged steaks and a wood‑paneled dining room — ideal for a classic New York night out. The dry‑aging room visible from the street adds old‑school authenticity and theatre‑district nostalgia.
Must-Try Dishes:
Dry‑aged rib‑eye, Prime rib (call ahead), Coal‑grilled porterhouse
What makes it special: Historic coal‑grilled steaks and authentic speakeasy‑era ambiance.
8.0
A Midtown pre-theater standby that blends steakhouse heft with Italian-American comfort. Regulars praise reliably well-executed chops alongside pastas and seafood, with a polished but unpretentious dining room. Strong choice for classic, crowd-pleasing dinners near Carnegie Hall.
Must-Try Dishes:
Bone-in ribeye, Jumbo shrimp scampi, Fresh mozzarella & tomato salad
What makes it special: Italian-leaning steakhouse menu that stays dependable for years.