Best Date Night Steakhouse Restaurants in Williamsburg (11211)
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: January 2026
Our Top Pick
Peter Luger Steak House
Legendary dry-aged porterhouse in a historic, wood-paneled dining room.
Notable Picks
8.9
Peter Luger is a century-plus-old Williamsburg institution where dry-aged porterhouse, old-school service, and wood-paneled dining rooms anchor big-night steaks. Couples come for shareable cuts, creamed spinach, and the feeling of eating at one of New York’s most storied steakhouses.
Must-Try Dishes:
Porterhouse for Two, Extra-Thick Sliced Bacon, Creamed Spinach
What makes it special: Legendary dry-aged porterhouse in a historic, wood-paneled dining room.
8.7
A classic steakhouse known for its perfectly aged steaks, DeStefano's offers a luxurious dining experience with exceptional service and an elegant atmosphere.
Must-Try Dishes:
Dry-Aged Porterhouse, Filet Mignon, Lobster Tail
What makes it special: Renowned for its perfectly cooked, dry-aged steaks.
#3
St. Anselm
8.4
St. Anselm is a narrow Williamsburg grill where an open kitchen, cast-iron sides, and a famous butcher’s steak make for a lively, lower-key steak date. It feels more like a tavern than a temple, with bar seats overlooking the grill and a crowd that skews neighborhood regulars and food-obsessed couples.
Must-Try Dishes:
Skirt Steak, Roasted Chicken, Charred Broccoli
What makes it special: Offers a great selection of meats, all cooked to perfection in a cozy setting.