Best Date Night Sushi Restaurants in Midtown Manhattan (10019)
4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: January 2026
Our Top Pick
Nobu Fifty Seven
Refined Japanese‑Peruvian sushi with polished presentation and consistently high quality.
Notable Picks
8.9
Upscale sushi and Japanese‑Peruvian fare in a sleek, stylish space — a go‑to for a special night out when you want refined eats and ambiance. Locals and visitors rely on its consistent high quality and elegant plating. Nobu Fifty Seven delivers reliably polished sushi and signature dishes with class.
Must-Try Dishes:
Black Cod Miso, Yellowtail Jalapeño, Toro Tartare
What makes it special: Refined Japanese‑Peruvian sushi with polished presentation and consistently high quality.
#2
Sushi Damo
8.3
A comfortable, unpretentious sushi spot near Columbus Circle offering well‑made nigiri and classic rolls — good for a relaxed date night without the fuss. It hits a sweet spot balancing quality and value for Midtown standards. Customers appreciate the modern yet approachable vibe and consistent sushi execution.
Must-Try Dishes:
Specialty Maki Rolls, Chef’s Nigiri Selection, Spicy Tuna Roll
What makes it special: Unpretentious sushi spot with modest prices and solid roll variety.
#3
Beyond Sushi
8.3
A date-night-friendly, plant-based sushi stop that wins on creativity and consistency: punchy sauces, clever textures, and rolls that feel like full dishes rather than substitutes. Best used as a relaxed, conversation-forward dinner when you want something lighter but still “planned.”
Must-Try Dishes:
Mighty Mushroom Roll, Mighty Mang Rolls, Vegan sushi (assorted rolls)
What makes it special: Vegan rolls with real flavor structure—built like composed dishes.
Worthy Picks
7.6
A modest mid‑block sushi spot offering straightforward rolls and nigiri — good for casual and affordable dinner dates without pretense. It doesn’t aim for luxury, but delivers decent drinks and sushi for the price, making it a reliable, low‑key option in Midtown. Portions and freshness are sufficient for a relaxed evening out.
Must-Try Dishes:
California Roll, Tuna Roll, Sake Nigiri Combo
What makes it special: Casual, budget‑friendly sushi in a central Midtown location.