What is the best Italian restaurant in Hell's Kitchen Midtown West?

John's Pizzeria of Times Square is our top pick for Italian restaurants in Hell's Kitchen Midtown West, scoring 8.7/10. Pizzeria in a converted church with stunning stained glass architecture

Any insider tips for John's Pizzeria of Times Square?

Make reservations despite casual vibe—waits can exceed 40 minutes

What should I order at John's Pizzeria of Times Square?

Classic thin-crust cheese pie with toppings of choice

When should I visit John's Pizzeria of Times Square?

Lunch or early pre-theater to avoid long waits

Who should go to John's Pizzeria of Times Square?

Families, budget-conscious groups, pizza purists

Any insider tips for Lattanzi Cucina Italiana?

Ask for the garlic matzoh—a signature from the Roman Jewish tradition

What should I order at Lattanzi Cucina Italiana?

Start with carciofi alla giudia, absolutely essential

When should I visit Lattanzi Cucina Italiana?

Tuesday nights or pre-theater dinner

Who should go to Lattanzi Cucina Italiana?

Food historians, theater patrons, celebrity spotters

Any insider tips for Tony's Di Napoli (Times Square)?

Half portions available at lunch—still feeds two comfortably

What should I order at Tony's Di Napoli (Times Square)?

Baked clams, chicken parm, meatballs

When should I visit Tony's Di Napoli (Times Square)?

Pre-MSG events or Broadway shows

Who should go to Tony's Di Napoli (Times Square)?

Groups, families, fans of classic Italian American red sauce

Any insider tips for Nizza?

Celiac-safe calamari is fried in a dedicated gluten-free fryer

What should I order at Nizza?

Gluten-free brick oven pizza, socca (chickpea flatbread)

When should I visit Nizza?

Weekend brunch or pre-theater dinner

Who should go to Nizza?

Gluten-free diners, health-conscious foodies, theater crowds

Best Family Friendly Italian Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen Midtown West (10036)

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

John's Pizzeria of Times Square

Pizzeria in a converted church with stunning stained glass architecture

Notable Picks

#1 John's Pizzeria of Times Square

8.7

$$ Times Square / Theater District

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Group Dining Gatherings Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Instagram Worthy Wonders

Classic coal‑oven pizzas and family‑style tables make this Times Square institution a go‑to for walk-in group dining and casual pizza night out.

Must-Try Dishes: Classic Cheese Pizza, Sausage and Peppers Pizza, Garlic Knots

What makes it special: Pizzeria in a converted church with stunning stained glass architecture

View Full Review →

#2 Lattanzi Cucina Italiana

8.5

$$$ Theatre District

Vibes: Date Night Magic Hidden Gems Heaven Business Lunch Power Players Outdoor Dining Oasis

Family-owned since 1984, this Restaurant Row townhouse specializes in Roman Jewish-style cuisine with signature carciofi alla giudia. SNL creator Lorne Michaels hosts weekly Tuesday dinners here, cementing its status as a Theater District institution.

Must-Try Dishes: Carciofi alla Giudia, Bucatini all'Amatriciana, Homemade Cannoli

What makes it special: Rare Roman Jewish-style Italian cuisine with famous deep-fried artichokes

View Full Review →

#3 Tony's Di Napoli (Times Square)

8.3

$$ Times Square / Theater District

Vibes: Group Dining Gatherings Family Friendly Favorites Birthday & Celebration Central Comfort Food Classics

Large red‑sauce platters and a bustling, high‑energy dining room make this spot a reliable choice for families or larger groups looking for familiar Italian‑American comfort food near Times Square.

Must-Try Dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Spaghetti and Meatballs, Veal Francese

What makes it special: Theatrical family-style service with enormous portions meant for sharing

View Full Review →

#4 Nizza

8.2

$$ Hell’s Kitchen

Vibes: Healthy Haven Date Night Magic Outdoor Dining Oasis Brunch Bliss Spots

Ligurian comfort food meets French Riviera influence at this Hell's Kitchen trattoria since 2007. Chef Andy D'Amico's extensive gluten-free program with dedicated fryers and separate menu sets it apart, alongside brick-oven pizzas and house-made pasta.

Must-Try Dishes: Gluten-Free Pizza, Linguine alle Vongole, Ricotta Cheesecake

What makes it special: One of NYC's most comprehensive gluten-free Italian menus with dedicated fryers

View Full Review →