What is the best Wings restaurant in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn?

Henry Street Ale House is our top pick for Wings restaurants in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn, scoring 8.2/10. Classic Brooklyn Heights ale house where wings pair with serious beer.

Any insider tips for Henry Street Ale House?

Check rotating tap lists; certain beers pair especially well with wings.

What should I order at Henry Street Ale House?

Buffalo wings, a house burger, and a rotating draft beer.

When should I visit Henry Street Ale House?

Happy hour or game nights for peak pub atmosphere.

Who should go to Henry Street Ale House?

Pub fans who want pints, sports, and solid wings.

Any insider tips for O'Keefe's Bar & Grill?

Arrive early for major games to lock down a booth with a clear TV view.

What should I order at O'Keefe's Bar & Grill?

Buffalo or teriyaki wings, burger, and a draft beer sampler.

When should I visit O'Keefe's Bar & Grill?

Game nights or weekday happy hour before evening crowds swell.

Who should go to O'Keefe's Bar & Grill?

Sports fans meeting friends for wings, beers, and big games.

Any insider tips for The Custom House?

Check daily specials; wing platters and pitchers often bundle into good value.

What should I order at The Custom House?

Buffalo wings, BBQ chicken flatbread, mac and cheese.

When should I visit The Custom House?

Weekday evenings for after-work pints and appetizer specials.

Who should go to The Custom House?

Groups wanting casual drinks, wings, and sports downtown.

Any insider tips for Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn?

Order a larger platter to share; wings stay crisp for a while.

What should I order at Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn?

Medium Buffalo wings, lemon pepper dozen, fries on the side.

When should I visit Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn?

Lunch or early evening before peak market crowds.

Who should go to Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn?

Wing purists who want classic Buffalo done right.

Best Happy Hour Wings Restaurants in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn (11201)

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Henry Street Ale House

Classic Brooklyn Heights ale house where wings pair with serious beer.

Notable Picks

#1 Henry Street Ale House

8.2

$ Brooklyn Heights

Vibes: Sports Bar Central Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Happy Hour Hotspots

Classic Brooklyn Heights ale house where locals crowd the bar for rotating drafts, burgers, and a well-loved plate of buffalo wings during weekday happy hour. It’s more about reliable pub comfort and neighborhood energy than polish, making it a straightforward choice for post-work beers and wings near the Promenade.

Must-Try Dishes: Buffalo wings, Chicken tenders, Burger with fries

What makes it special: Classic Brooklyn Heights ale house where wings pair with serious beer.

View Full Review →

#2 O'Keefe's Bar & Grill

8.1

$$$ Brooklyn Heights

Vibes: Sports Bar Central Happy Hour Hotspots Group Dining Gatherings Late Night Legends

Long-running Brooklyn Heights sports bar pouring plenty of draft beer with a menu that leans heavily on bar staples like buffalo and teriyaki wings. Big TVs, late hours, and steady happy hour deals make it a go-to spot for catching a game over wings and pitchers near the courts and subway hubs.

Must-Try Dishes: Buffalo wings, Teriyaki wings, O'Keefe's burger

What makes it special: Old-school sports bar with plenty of TVs and big plates of wings.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 The Custom House

7.9

$$$ Brooklyn Heights

Vibes: Happy Hour Hotspots Sports Bar Central Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings

Casual Montague Street pub with a long stone bar, multiple TVs, and a menu where buffalo wings are a staple alongside flatbreads and pub mains. It’s popular for relaxed happy hours, office gatherings, and low-key sports watching in the heart of Brooklyn Heights.

Must-Try Dishes: Buffalo wings with blue cheese, BBQ chicken flatbread, Mac and cheese

What makes it special: Montague Street pub where wings, flatbreads, and happy hour overlap with wall-to-wall sports.

View Full Review →

#4 Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn

7.8

$ Downtown Brooklyn

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Comfort Food Classics Food Hall Frenzy Group Dining Gatherings

Wing-focused stall inside DeKalb Market Hall where the menu runs through classic buffalo, dry rub, and sauce-driven options that pair easily with nearby bar stalls. Office workers and arena-goers treat it as a quick stop for serious wings before or after happy hour drinks in the complex.

Must-Try Dishes: Medium Buffalo wings, Lemon pepper wings, Garlic parmesan wings

What makes it special: Buffalo-native owners serving crisp, saucy wings in a central food hall.

View Full Review →