What is the best Cream restaurant in Gramercy & Flatiron?

Tipsy Scoop is our top pick for Cream restaurants in Gramercy & Flatiron, scoring 8.4/10. Boozy ice cream built like cocktails—best ordered as a flight.

Any insider tips for Tipsy Scoop?

Split a flight first—then commit to one full scoop.

What should I order at Tipsy Scoop?

Ice cream flight, Dark Chocolate Whiskey, seasonal sorbet

When should I visit Tipsy Scoop?

After dinner, before the late rush

Who should go to Tipsy Scoop?

Dessert people who want a nightlife edge

Any insider tips for La Gelateria di Eataly?

Mix one rich flavor with one fruit sorbet for balance.

What should I order at La Gelateria di Eataly?

Pistachio, stracciatella, one seasonal sorbetto

When should I visit La Gelateria di Eataly?

Mid-afternoon for the shortest wait

Who should go to La Gelateria di Eataly?

Gelato purists and quick dessert walkers

Any insider tips for Cha Cha Matcha (Flatiron)?

Order straight matcha first—then try the swirl next visit.

What should I order at Cha Cha Matcha (Flatiron)?

Matcha soft serve, matcha-ube swirl, one lemonade

Who should go to Cha Cha Matcha (Flatiron)?

Matcha lovers and light-dessert people

Any insider tips for Cone Club?

Pair one rich scoop with one fruit scoop for balance.

What should I order at Cone Club?

Dulce de Leche, Dark Chocolate, Passion Fruit

Who should go to Cone Club?

Anyone chasing dessert after hours

Best Ice Cream Restaurants in Gramercy & Flatiron (10010)

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Tipsy Scoop

Boozy ice cream built like cocktails—best ordered as a flight.

Notable Picks

#1 Tipsy Scoop

8.4

$$ Kips Bay

Vibes: Sweet Treats Escapes Trendy Table Hotspots Girls Night Out Approved Birthday & Celebration Central

A boozy-ice-cream bar that’s strongest when you treat it like a tasting flight: tight scoops, clean flavors, and just enough alcohol to read as dessert, not gimmick. Go for the signature spiked combinations and skip over-ordering—two scoops plus one seasonal special is the sweet spot.

Must-Try Dishes: Boozy ice cream flight, Dark Chocolate Whiskey Salted Pretzel, Mango Margarita sorbet

What makes it special: Boozy ice cream built like cocktails—best ordered as a flight.

View Full Review →

#2 La Gelateria di Eataly

8.1

$$ Flatiron

Vibes: Sweet Treats Escapes Quick Bites Champions Solo Dining Sanctuaries

A focused gelato counter that wins on clean dairy flavor and classic Italian execution—smooth textures, sharp ingredient definition, and minimal fuss. Order like an Italian: one nut flavor, one cream flavor, and a sorbetto as a palate reset.

Must-Try Dishes: Pistachio gelato, Stracciatella, Seasonal fruit sorbetto

What makes it special: Classic gelato textures with clear, ingredient-forward flavor.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 Cha Cha Matcha (Flatiron)

7.9

$ Flatiron

Vibes: Sweet Treats Escapes Instagram Worthy Wonders Quick Bites Champions Solo Dining Sanctuaries

A matcha-first cafe where the ice-cream move is soft serve that stays smooth and tea-forward rather than sugary. The best orders keep it simple: straight matcha, a swirl, and one bright topping if you want contrast.

Must-Try Dishes: Matcha soft serve, Matcha + ube swirl soft serve, Matcha affogato-style pour-over

What makes it special: Matcha soft serve that tastes like tea, not candy.

View Full Review →

#4 Cone Club

7.6

$ Flatiron

Vibes: Sweet Treats Escapes Late Night Legends Quick Bites Champions Hidden Gems Heaven

A late-leaning cone spot built for quick, satisfying scoops—classic flavors, straightforward builds, and an easy in-and-out rhythm. Keep the order tight: one dairy flavor plus one fruit flavor, and skip over-complicating it.

Must-Try Dishes: Dulce de Leche cone, Dark Chocolate scoop, Passion Fruit scoop

What makes it special: Late-night cones with simple, crowd-pleasing flavors.

View Full Review →