What is the best Cream restaurant in Wicker Park & West Town?

Black Dog Gelato is our top pick for Cream restaurants in Wicker Park & West Town, scoring 8.6/10. Chef-driven gelato with signature flavors like goat cheese cashew caramel in a compact neighborhood shop.

Any insider tips for Black Dog Gelato?

Ask which flavors are in the signature collection that day; they often sell out first.

What should I order at Black Dog Gelato?

Goat Cheese Cashew Caramel, Mint Cookie, a dairy-free seasonal scoop.

When should I visit Black Dog Gelato?

Evenings and warm weekends before lines spill onto Damen.

Who should go to Black Dog Gelato?

Gelato fans who want bold, rotating flavors.

Any insider tips for The Original Rainbow Cone?

Use sundaes as your move if you really want mini donuts—their signature creations layer hot donuts directly into the ice cream build.

What should I order at The Original Rainbow Cone?

Fresh Mini Donuts, Cookies & Cream Crunch, an Original Rainbow Cone slice.

When should I visit The Original Rainbow Cone?

Afternoons and early evenings before peak summer lines.

Who should go to The Original Rainbow Cone?

Families and friends planning a dessert-focused outing.

Any insider tips for VinnyD's?

Bring your dog; the walk-up setup and hours make it an easy post-walk treat stop.

What should I order at VinnyD's?

Italian cookie gelato, blood orange Italian ice, a Chicago dog.

When should I visit VinnyD's?

Warm evenings and late nights when Division Street is buzzing.

Who should go to VinnyD's?

Night owls and neighborhood regulars craving dessert or beef.

Any insider tips for Kurimu?

Check their socials before you go; limited-time flavors and collabs change often.

What should I order at Kurimu?

Uji Matcha soft serve, Tea Time Parfait, an ube swirl.

When should I visit Kurimu?

Early evenings and weekend afternoons before peak crowds.

Who should go to Kurimu?

Dessert lovers chasing creative flavors and seasonal collabs.

Best Ice Cream Restaurants in Wicker Park & West Town (60622)

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Black Dog Gelato

Chef-driven gelato with signature flavors like goat cheese cashew caramel in a compact neighborhood shop.

Notable Picks

#1 Black Dog Gelato

8.6

$ Ukrainian Village

Vibes: Sweet Treats Escapes Quick Bites Champions Hidden Gems Heaven Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Black Dog Gelato’s Damen Avenue shop is a small, always-busy counter turning out dense, chef-driven gelato in rotating flavors like goat cheese cashew caramel and seasonal dairy-free options. Locals treat it as the go-to scoop stop after dinner on Division or Damen, with a reputation for inventive combinations over endless toppings.

Must-Try Dishes: Goat Cheese Cashew Caramel gelato, Mint Cookie gelato, Dairy Free Cranberry Orange Creamsicle

What makes it special: Chef-driven gelato with signature flavors like goat cheese cashew caramel in a compact neighborhood shop.

View Full Review →

#2 The Original Rainbow Cone

8.3

$ Wicker Park

Vibes: Birthday & Celebration Central Family Friendly Favorites Sweet Treats Escapes Instagram Worthy Wonders

This Wicker Park outpost of Chicago’s 1926-born Original Rainbow Cone serves thick slices of chocolate, strawberry, Palmer House, pistachio, and orange sherbet stacked onto a single cone. It’s where neighborhood families and late-night dessert runs converge when they want a classic South Side treat without leaving Division Street.

Must-Try Dishes: Fresh Mini Donuts, Cookies & Cream Crunch Sundae, Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge Sundae

What makes it special: A neighborhood outpost of Chicago’s nearly century-old ice cream brand that pairs its famous sliced cones with fresh mini donuts and sundae-style donut desserts.

View Full Review →

#3 VinnyD's

8.2

$ West Town

Vibes: Late Night Legends Sweet Treats Escapes Quick Bites Champions Pet Friendly Paradise

VinnyD’s is a family-owned walk-up stand known as much for Italian beef and Chicago dogs as for its gelato, Italian ice, and shakes. Since 2017 it’s become a late-night staple where West Town regulars grab blood orange or blue raspberry ice after a bar crawl or dog walk.

Must-Try Dishes: Italian cookie gelato, Blood orange and lemon Italian ice, Blue raspberry and cherry Italian ice

What makes it special: Walk-up window for Italian ice, gelato, and late-night Chicago staples in one stop.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#4 Kurimu

7.9

$$$ Wicker Park

Vibes: Sweet Treats Escapes Trendy Table Hotspots Quick Bites Champions Instagram Worthy Wonders

Kurimu brings rotating soft-serve flavors, parfaits, and collaborations to a bright, design-forward space on Division. The menu leans into Asian-inspired profiles like Uji matcha and ube, drawing dessert hunters who want something more playful than a classic scoop shop.

Must-Try Dishes: Uji Matcha soft serve, Tea Time Parfait, Ube soft serve

What makes it special: Rotating soft-serve and parfaits with Asian-inspired flavors in a stylish space.

View Full Review →