What is the best Burgers restaurant in Bay Ridge?

Skinflints is our top pick for Burgers restaurants in Bay Ridge, scoring 8.3/10. A Bay Ridge institution for festive comfort food with a reliable burger lane.

Any insider tips for Skinflints?

Order the burger classic-style—skip heavy add-ons and let the kitchen stay in its lane.

When should I visit Skinflints?

Weekend evenings for peak atmosphere

Who should go to Skinflints?

Groups doing comfort-food and celebration dinners

Any insider tips for The Wicked Monk?

Go early on your first round of food—kitchens stay steadier before the late rush.

When should I visit The Wicked Monk?

After 10pm, especially Thu–Sat

Who should go to The Wicked Monk?

Groups chasing beers and late food

Any insider tips for The Kettle Black?

Order the burger and fries first—add wings only if the table’s still hungry.

When should I visit The Kettle Black?

Weeknight evenings for easier seating

Who should go to The Kettle Black?

Groups watching games who want a burger

Any insider tips for Bay Ridge House of Wings?

Order one burger and one fry—skip extra sides until you’ve tasted the seasoning.

Who should go to Bay Ridge House of Wings?

Solo takeout runs and late-night snack missions

Best Late Night Burgers Restaurants in Bay Ridge (11209)

Q: What should I order at Skinflints?

Bacon cheddar burger, French onion soup, chicken pot pie

Q: What should I order at The Wicked Monk?

Burger, fish and chips, Reuben spring rolls

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: March 2026

Save

Our Top Pick

Skinflints

A Bay Ridge institution for festive comfort food with a reliable burger lane.

Notable Picks

#1 Skinflints

8.3

$$ Bay Ridge

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Birthday & Celebration Central Family Friendly Favorites Happy Hour Hotspots

A Bay Ridge tavern-restaurant that wins on classic American comfort and the kind of big, festive dining room locals use for birthdays and winter-season nights out. The burger lane is best when you keep it traditional—cheese, bacon, and fries—then let the old-school menu do what it’s always done: steady, hearty, and familiar.

Must-Try Dishes: Bacon Cheddar Burger, French Onion Soup, Chicken Pot Pie

What Makes it Special: A Bay Ridge institution for festive comfort food with a reliable burger lane.

View Full Review →

#2 The Wicked Monk

8.0

$$ Fort Hamilton

Vibes: Late Night Legends Brewery & Beer Garden Republic Live Music Showtime Group Dining Gatherings

A Fort Hamilton/Bay Ridge beer-bar hang that runs late and works best as a burger-and-a-pint stop when the group wants noise, screens, and a full kitchen past midnight. Lean into bar-food strengths—burger, fries, and one shareable starter—rather than ordering across the whole menu.

Must-Try Dishes: Burger, Fish and Chips, Reuben Spring Rolls

What Makes it Special: Late-running beer-bar energy with a dependable burger-and-fries move.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 The Kettle Black

7.8

$$ Fort Hamilton

Vibes: Sports Bar Central Happy Hour Hotspots Group Dining Gatherings Comfort Food Classics

A long-running Bay Ridge sports bar where the burger play is strongest when you treat it like game-night fuel: one signature burger, one fry, and a beer. It’s not a destination burger shop, but it is a reliable “we need food and TVs” late-evening option with enough volume to suggest repeatable execution over time.

Must-Try Dishes: Texas Dunk Burger, Sweet Fries, Buffalo Wings

What Makes it Special: Sports-bar comfort where a signature burger and fries fits the mission.

View Full Review →

#4 Bay Ridge House of Wings

7.6

$ Fort Hamilton

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Hidden Gems Heaven Solo Dining Sanctuaries

A counter-service, takeout-friendly wing spot that quietly doubles as a late-evening burger fix—especially if you’re craving a straightforward smash-style build with fries. Keep the order focused (one burger, one side, one sauce-driven wing piece) and it delivers the “fast, salty, satisfying” lane better than trying to sample everything.

Must-Try Dishes: Smash Burger, Waffle Fries, Buffalo Wings

What Makes it Special: A wings-first counter that sneaks in a strong smash-burger-and-fries play.

View Full Review →