What is the best Mexican restaurant in Sunset Park?

Ricos Tacos is our top pick for Mexican restaurants in Sunset Park, scoring 8.4/10. High-volume, late-hours Mexican spot where tacos share billing with big plates and tortas.

Any insider tips for Ricos Tacos?

Order a torta and a taco plate to split; portions run large and filling.

What should I order at Ricos Tacos?

Pierna adobada tacos, chilaquiles rojos, a loaded torta to share.

When should I visit Ricos Tacos?

Late nights or weekend afternoons for peak energy and turnover.

Who should go to Ricos Tacos?

Hungry night owls and locals who want hearty Mexican classics.

Any insider tips for Jalapeños?

Portions are big—split a fajita platter and add an extra appetizer instead.

What should I order at Jalapeños?

Mixed fajitas, enchiladas estilo Jalapeños, bistec a la Mexicana.

When should I visit Jalapeños?

Weeknights around 6–8pm before it gets slammed.

Who should go to Jalapeños?

Families and groups wanting sit-down Mexican comfort.

Any insider tips for Tacos Los Poblanos #3?

Build a mixed taco order and ask for extra salsa verde on the side.

What should I order at Tacos Los Poblanos #3?

Tacos al pastor, a mix of carnitas tacos, and a quesillo torta.

When should I visit Tacos Los Poblanos #3?

Early evening when the grill is busiest and tacos are freshest.

Who should go to Tacos Los Poblanos #3?

Taco purists looking for quick, affordable street-style options.

Any insider tips for La Cabaña Mexican Restaurant?

Ask about off-menu specials—staff often highlight seafood or steak plates.

What should I order at La Cabaña Mexican Restaurant?

Steak ranchero, torta de pollo asado, a round of margaritas.

When should I visit La Cabaña Mexican Restaurant?

Evenings after 7pm for a livelier room and bar energy.

Who should go to La Cabaña Mexican Restaurant?

Small groups planning relaxed, drink-friendly Mexican dinners.

Any insider tips for Isabella's Mexican Restaurant?

Delivery is fast—use it when you want hot food without leaving home.

When should I visit Isabella's Mexican Restaurant?

Mornings for breakfast plates, late evenings for delivery cravings.

Who should go to Isabella's Mexican Restaurant?

Locals wanting dependable, no-frills Mexican comfort food.

Best Late Night Mexican Restaurants in Sunset Park (11220)

5 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Ricos Tacos

High-volume, late-hours Mexican spot where tacos share billing with big plates and tortas.

Notable Picks

#1 Ricos Tacos

8.4

$$ Sunset Park - 51st Street Corridor

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Late Night Legends Quick Bites Champions Group Dining Gatherings

Ricos Tacos is a 51st Street institution, running long hours for tacos, tortas, and full plates that fuel neighborhood regulars day and night. The menu leans hearty, with griddled meats, chilaquiles, and overstuffed sandwiches served in a no-frills dining room.

Must-Try Dishes: Tacos de pierna adobada, Chilaquiles rojos con cecina, Pierna adobada torta

What makes it special: High-volume, late-hours Mexican spot where tacos share billing with big plates and tortas.

View Full Review →

#2 Jalapeños

8.2

$$ Sunset Park

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Group Dining Gatherings Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions

Jalapeños is a busy Fifth Avenue standby where sizzling fajitas, house enchiladas, and big combination plates draw families and groups. With hundreds of recent delivery and dine-in reviews, it’s a reliable choice when you want a full sit-down Mexican meal rather than just a quick taco run.

Must-Try Dishes: Sizzling fajitas platters, Enchiladas estilo Jalapeños, Bistec a la Mexicana

What makes it special: Large, crowd-pleasing menu with fajitas and platters built for sharing.

View Full Review →

#3 Tacos Los Poblanos #3

8.0

$ Sunset Park - 5th Avenue Hub

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Quick Bites Champions Hidden Gems Heaven

Tacos Los Poblanos #3 is a compact 5th Avenue storefront focused on classic street-style tacos at wallet-friendly prices. Freshly griddled tortillas, a focused menu, and late-afternoon-to-late-night hours make it a reliable stop for quick taco runs.

Must-Try Dishes: Taco al pastor, Carnitas tacos, Quesillo torta

What makes it special: Tight, taco-focused shop where al pastor and other fillings stay front and center.

View Full Review →

#4 La Cabaña Mexican Restaurant

8.0

$ Sunset Park – Mid 5th Avenue

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Birthday & Celebration Central Trendy Table Hotspots

La Cabaña Mexican Restaurant is a cozy Fifth Avenue dining room known for steak ranchero, tortas, and margaritas served late into the evening. With a slightly more polished feel than some nearby taquerías, it works well for casual celebrations, small-group dinners, and relaxed nights over plates and drinks.

Must-Try Dishes: Steak ranchero with rice and beans, Torta de pollo asado, Enchiladas with house sauces

What makes it special: Cozy neighborhood restaurant where steak plates and tortas pair with cocktails.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#5 Isabella's Mexican Restaurant

7.8

$ Sunset Park - 4th Avenue Corridor

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Comfort Food Classics Solo Dining Sanctuaries

A neighborhood Mexican restaurant-bar on 4th Avenue serving combo plates, tacos, and drinks until close to midnight. The room leans more casual than polished, but it’s useful for late-night sit-down meals with friends or a low-key date.

Must-Try Dishes: Torta milanesa de pollo, Chicken burrito, Nachos locos with steak

What makes it special: Everyday neighborhood spot for affordable tortas, burritos, and breakfast plates.

View Full Review →