Best Late Night Pizza Restaurants in Soho (10012)
6 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: January 2026
Our Top Pick
Prince Street Pizza
Legendary Sicilian squares with thick, caramelized crusts and overloaded toppings served from a standing-room-only Nolita slice shop.
Notable Picks
8.9
Since 2012, this Nolita slice shop has drawn late-night lines for its thick Sicilian “SoHo Square” and cup-and-char pepperoni slices. The standing-room setup, quick-moving counter, and 3 a.m. weekend hours make it a go-to after-bar stop as well as a daytime pizza pilgrimage.
Must-Try Dishes:
Spicy Spring Sicilian Square, SoHo Square Sicilian Slice, Vodka Sauce Sicilian Slice
What makes it special: Legendary Sicilian squares with thick, caramelized crusts and overloaded toppings served from a standing-room-only Nolita slice shop.
#2
Emmett's
8.6
Opened in 2013 by Chicago native Emmett Burke, this South Village spot brings cast-iron deep dish and tavern-style pies to a cozy, wood-paneled room that hums late into the night. It’s more of a sit-down pizzeria than a slice joint, with made-to-order pies that reward the wait with blistered crusts and gooey centers.
Must-Try Dishes:
Sausage deep dish pizza, Pepperoni deep dish pizza, Chicago Italian beef sandwich
What makes it special: Chicago-style deep dish and tavern pies done with New York ingredients and serious craft.
8.4
Founded by World Pizza Champion Hakkı Akdeniz, this SoHo outpost serves thin, crackly-crust rounds and overloaded square slices until 2–4 a.m. depending on the night. The long, narrow room stays buzzy with tourists and locals working through trays of creative toppings under walls of celebrity photos.
Must-Try Dishes:
Buffalo Chicken Slice, Margherita Slice, Loaded Square Slice of the Day
What makes it special: High-volume slice shop for thin, saucy squares and creative topping combinations right off Cleveland Place.
8.0
A newer SoHo entrant, Crazy Pizza combines ultra-thin Roman-style pies, tableside truffle shavings, and DJ-backed dough-spinning shows in a clubby dining room. Open late on weekends, it functions as both pizzeria and party, drawing fashion and nightlife crowds more than grab-and-go slice hunters.
Must-Try Dishes:
Black truffle pizza, Diavola spicy salami pizza, Burrata and cherry tomato pizza
What makes it special: High-energy, performance-driven pizzeria where wafer-thin pies share the spotlight with DJs and dough-spinning servers.
Worthy Picks
#5
Nolita Pizza
7.9
Co-founded by a Bleecker Street Pizza veteran, this counter-service spot elevates the neighborhood slice with imported ingredients, house marinara, and properly aged mozzarella. The gluten-free options are legitimately good, and the late-night hours make it a go-to for after-hours pizza cravings.
Must-Try Dishes:
Vodka Pie, Gluten-Free Margherita, Pepperoni Slice
What makes it special: Quality slice shop with imported Italian ingredients and strong gluten-free game
7.9
A SoHo staple since 1979, Famous Ben’s is known for its Palermo-style Sicilian slices and old-school corner-pizzeria feel. Open past midnight most nights, it’s where shop workers, film crews, and longtime locals still duck in for hearty, sauce-forward squares and classic New York pies.
Must-Try Dishes:
Sicilian Square Slice, Classic Cheese Slice, Baked Ziti or Pasta Plate
What makes it special: Long-running SoHo slice shop from 1979 known for thick Sicilian squares and a roster of film and TV appearances.