What is the best Pizza restaurant in The Outer Sunset?

Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave) is our top pick for Pizza restaurants in The Outer Sunset, scoring 8.1/10. Open very late with fast, reliable slices.

Any insider tips for Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)?

Ask for extra-crisp reheat on slices after midnight.

What should I order at Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)?

Chick-O-Oni slice, wings, garlic knots

When should I visit Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)?

After 11pm when most Sunset kitchens close

Who should go to Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)?

Night owls needing quick, filling pizza

Any insider tips for Pirro’s Pizzeria?

Call ahead—counter pick-up is faster than third-party apps.

What should I order at Pirro’s Pizzeria?

Sicilian square, combo pie, garlic bread

When should I visit Pirro’s Pizzeria?

Early evening before peak delivery rush

Who should go to Pirro’s Pizzeria?

Families and classic pizza loyalists

Any insider tips for North Beach Pizza (Taraval)?

The by-the-slice selection rotates throughout the day — ask what just came out of the oven for the freshest pick

What should I order at North Beach Pizza (Taraval)?

Grab slices at the counter for a fast meal, or split a whole combo pie with garlic bread on the side

When should I visit North Beach Pizza (Taraval)?

Weeknight evenings for quick service without weekend waits

Who should go to North Beach Pizza (Taraval)?

Budget-minded pizza lovers in the Outer Sunset

Any insider tips for Brothers Pizza?

Call ahead—ribs can sell out on busy weekends.

What should I order at Brothers Pizza?

BBQ pork ribs; side salad; a slice to share

When should I visit Brothers Pizza?

Early evenings before the dinner rush

Who should go to Brothers Pizza?

Casual groups with mixed cravings

Best Late Night Pizza Restaurants in The Outer Sunset (94116)

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: June 2026

Save

Our Top Pick

Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)

Open very late with fast, reliable slices.

Notable Picks

#1 Seniore’s Pizza (19th Ave)

8.1

$ Parkside

Vibes: Late Night Legends Quick Bites Champions Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Counter-service slice shop known for late-night hours (often past 1am) and crowd-pleasing specialty pies. Locals lean on it after games or late shifts for fast slices, wings, and hearty combos.

Must-Try Dishes: Chick-O-Oni (pesto chicken + pepperoni, white sauce), Pepperoni & jalapeño slice, Garlic knots

What Makes it Special: Open very late with fast, reliable slices.

View Full Review →

#2 Pirro’s Pizzeria

8.0

$ Parkside

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Quick Bites Champions

Neighborhood fixture dating to 1954 known for hand-spun pies, Sicilian squares, and a classic red-sauce menu. People come for nostalgic flavors, fair prices, and reliable takeout on busy evenings.

Must-Try Dishes: Sicilian Square Pizza, Pirro’s Special Combo Pie, Garlic Bread

What Makes it Special: Decades-strong pizzeria with hand-spun pies and Sicilian trays.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 North Beach Pizza (Taraval)

7.7

$ Parkside

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance

A Taraval Street slice shop built on hand-spun dough and whole milk mozzarella, priced for the neighborhood rather than the destination crowd. Outer Sunset regulars treat it as a default weeknight option—generous portions, reliable by-the-slice rotation, and a clams-and-garlic pie that gives the menu a slight edge over generic delivery competitors.

Must-Try Dishes: Garlic Bread, Cheese Pizza by the Slice, Combo Special Pizza

What Makes it Special: Hand-spun dough and whole milk mozzarella at neighborhood prices, with generous portions that keep Outer Sunset regulars coming back

View Full Review →

#4 Brothers Pizza

7.7

$ Parkside

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings

Neighborhood pizzeria that also serves a hearty BBQ pork ribs plate alongside pies and pastas. A reliable, family-friendly option when someone wants ribs and others want pizza.

Must-Try Dishes: BBQ Pork Ribs, BBQ Chicken, Garlic Bread

What Makes it Special: Unexpected but satisfying ribs from a long-running Taraval pizza shop.

View Full Review →