Best Mexican Restaurants in West Village (10014)
5 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: January 2026
Our Top Pick
Jajaja Mexicana
High-volume, fully plant-based Mexican with serious cocktail game.
Notable Picks
8.7
Plant-based Mexican plates and mezcal-forward cocktails anchor this lively West Village outpost of the Jajaja group. Expect vibrant vegan tacos, birria-style plates, and a packed bar scene that runs from brunch through late night.
Must-Try Dishes:
Our Birria Tacos, Taco Tazón, Mezcal Margarita
What makes it special: High-volume, fully plant-based Mexican with serious cocktail game.
#2
Ofrenda
8.3
Since 2010, Ofrenda has served polished Mexican plates and tequila-heavy cocktails in a narrow, candlelit room just off Sheridan Square. Locals lean on it for happy hour margs, guacamole, and late-night tacos with a West Village crowd.
Must-Try Dishes:
Ofrenda Guacamole, Smoky Jalapeño Margarita, Shrimp Tacos
What makes it special: Long-running tequila cantina with serious margaritas and late hours.
Worthy Picks
7.9
This cash-only food truck parked off W 4th has a cult following for oversized burritos and late-night tacos at true neighborhood prices. It’s a no-frills operation serving Puebla-style comfort food to bar-hoppers and industry workers until the early morning.
Must-Try Dishes:
Spicy Pork Burrito, Roast Pork Tacos, Chicken Torta
What makes it special: Late-night truck turning out hefty, deeply flavored burritos and tacos.
7.8
Alex Stupak’s West Village taqueria leans creative, pairing cheffy tacos with a deep agave list in a dim, bar-forward space. High-volume crowds come for inventive fillings like fish tempura and ayocote bean flautas rather than strict traditionalism.
Must-Try Dishes:
Fish Tempura Tacos, Ayocote Bean Flautas, Seven Salsas with Tortilla Chips
What makes it special: Chef-driven tacos and mezcal in a polished bar setting.
7.6
A neighborhood Tex-Mex fixture with roots dating back to the early ’90s, Mole West Village focuses on crowd-pleasers: brisket tacos, mole enchiladas, and tableside guacamole backed by a deep tequila list. It’s more about generous plates and casual comfort than precision cooking.
Must-Try Dishes:
Mole Enchiladas, Brisket Tacos, Tableside Guacamole
What makes it special: Long-running Tex-Mex spot with big portions and tableside guac.