What is the best Pizza restaurant in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn?

Juliana's is our top pick for Pizza restaurants in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn, scoring 8.9/10. Coal-oven pies from Patsy Grimaldi at his original bridge-side address.

Any insider tips for Juliana's?

If the line is long, order a whole pie to stay and a take-and-bake pie for later.

What should I order at Juliana's?

Margherita, white pie, half-pepperoni half-Margherita combo.

When should I visit Juliana's?

Early lunch or late afternoon to minimize the line.

Who should go to Juliana's?

Pizza fans chasing a benchmark Dumbo coal-oven experience.

Any insider tips for Grimaldi's Pizzeria?

Split a couple of large pies for variety; the crust holds up best eaten on-site.

What should I order at Grimaldi's Pizzeria?

Traditional Margherita, pepperoni pie, shared salad for the table.

When should I visit Grimaldi's Pizzeria?

Midafternoon or early evening before peak bridge-walk crowds.

Who should go to Grimaldi's Pizzeria?

First-time visitors wanting a classic New York coal-oven stop.

Any insider tips for Sottocasa Pizzeria?

Ask for the chili oil and sit near the back garden area when weather allows.

What should I order at Sottocasa Pizzeria?

Margherita, Salsiccia, a Nutella pizza to share for dessert.

When should I visit Sottocasa Pizzeria?

Weeknights after 7 for a relaxed, candlelit vibe.

Who should go to Sottocasa Pizzeria?

Couples and small groups craving Neapolitan-style pies and wine.

Any insider tips for Table 87 - Brooklyn Heights?

Use the bar area for solo pizza and a drink when tables are packed.

What should I order at Table 87 - Brooklyn Heights?

Margherita slice, prosciutto and arugula pie, coal-oven wings.

When should I visit Table 87 - Brooklyn Heights?

Happy hour or early evening for slices, drinks, and less wait.

Who should go to Table 87 - Brooklyn Heights?

Dinosaurs needing flexible options from slices to full dinners.

Any insider tips for Ignazio's Pizza?

Request a table by the windows to better enjoy the bridge views.

What should I order at Ignazio's Pizza?

Siciliana, shrimp pizza, Tex Mex or veggie specialty pie.

When should I visit Ignazio's Pizza?

Late lunch or early dinner before peak evening rush.

Who should go to Ignazio's Pizza?

Diners wanting sit-down pizza near the bridge without huge lines.

Any insider tips for L&B Spumoni Gardens?

Grab a square and spumoni, then walk a few minutes to eat by the water.

What should I order at L&B Spumoni Gardens?

Sicilian square pie, round cheese pie, classic tricolor spumoni.

When should I visit L&B Spumoni Gardens?

Afternoons or early evenings before peak bridge and tourist traffic.

Who should go to L&B Spumoni Gardens?

Fans of thick-crust Sicilian squares and old-school spumoni.

Any insider tips for Front Street Pizza?

Build a mixed pie by ordering several different whole-pie toppings for groups.

What should I order at Front Street Pizza?

Cheese slice, Buffalo chicken slice, garlic knots on the side.

When should I visit Front Street Pizza?

Lunch and early evening when the slice case is fullest.

Who should go to Front Street Pizza?

People needing a fast, affordable slice near the DUMBO waterfront.

Best Pizza Restaurants in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn (11201)

7 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Juliana's

Coal-oven pies from Patsy Grimaldi at his original bridge-side address.

Notable Picks

#1 Juliana's

8.9

$$$ DUMBO

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Family Friendly Favorites Trendy Table Hotspots

Juliana's, founded by coal-oven legend Patsy Grimaldi in 2012, serves thin, blistered New York-style pies baked in an 800°F coal oven under the Brooklyn Bridge. Lines form for classics like the Margherita and white pie, which locals and visitors treat as a benchmark for Dumbo pizza.

Must-Try Dishes: Margherita pizza, White pie with mozzarella and garlic, Pepperoni and sausage Special No. 1

What makes it special: Coal-oven pies from Patsy Grimaldi at his original bridge-side address.

View Full Review →

#2 Grimaldi's Pizzeria

8.6

$$$ DUMBO

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Family Friendly Favorites Birthday & Celebration Central

Grimaldi's flagship under the bridge remains a classic New York stop for coal-fired pies with a crackling crust and tangy sauce. Tourists and longtime regulars pack the multi-level space for big family-style pizzas and old-school New York ambiance.

Must-Try Dishes: Traditional coal-fired Margherita pizza, Pepperoni pizza, Calzone with ricotta and mozzarella

What makes it special: Long-running coal-oven institution that helped put DUMBO pizza on the map.

View Full Review →

#3 Sottocasa Pizzeria

8.5

$$$ Boerum Hill

Vibes: Date Night Magic Hidden Gems Heaven Comfort Food Classics Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Sottocasa in Boerum Hill focuses on VPN-style Neapolitan pies baked in a wood-fired oven, with imported ingredients and a cozy townhouse setting. Locals lean on it for date nights and small-group dinners where the Margherita and seasonal specials lead the order.

Must-Try Dishes: Margherita pizza, Salsiccia pizza with hot Italian sausage, Nutella dessert pizza

What makes it special: Wood-fired Neapolitan pies in a townhouse space that feels like a neighborhood dining room.

View Full Review →

#4 Table 87 - Brooklyn Heights

8.3

$$ Brooklyn Heights

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Comfort Food Classics Trendy Table Hotspots Business Lunch Power Players

Table 87 bills itself as the "Home of the Coal Oven Slice," pairing coal-fired pies and by-the-slice options with a full menu of Italian plates and cocktails. The Brooklyn Heights location doubles as a neighborhood hangout where you can grab a quick slice at the counter or settle into the back dining room for a longer meal.

Must-Try Dishes: Margherita coal-oven slice, Prosciutto and arugula pizza, Square veggie pie

What makes it special: Coal-oven slices, a full Italian menu, and cocktails under one roof.

View Full Review →

#5 Ignazio's Pizza

8.1

$$$ DUMBO

Vibes: Hidden Gems Heaven Date Night Magic Group Dining Gatherings Instagram Worthy Wonders

Ignazio's sits just off the waterfront near the Brooklyn Bridge, serving gas-fired brick-oven pies with both classic and creative topping combinations. It draws a mix of locals and visitors who want sit-down service, big salads, and specialty pies without the coal-oven crowds next door.

Must-Try Dishes: Siciliana pizza, Shrimp pizza with bacon and roasted peppers, Tex Mex specialty pizza

What makes it special: Brick-oven pies with creative toppings a short stroll from the bridge.

View Full Review →

#6 L&B Spumoni Gardens

8.0

$$$ DUMBO

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Family Friendly Favorites Sweet Treats Escapes

The Dumbo outpost of L&B Spumoni Gardens brings the Gravesend legend’s upside-down Sicilian squares and tri-flavor spumoni to Old Fulton Street. Opened in late 2024, it offers square pies, round pies, and Italian-American comfort dishes in a narrow, modern space steps from the waterfront.

Must-Try Dishes: Upside-down Sicilian square slice, Round cheese pie, Rainbow spumoni

What makes it special: Beloved 1939 Brooklyn square-pizza institution now serving upside-down Sicilian slices in DUMBO.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#7 Front Street Pizza

7.9

$ DUMBO

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Family Friendly Favorites Comfort Food Classics

Front Street Pizza is a long-running DUMBO slice shop and deli known for fast-moving lines, large pies, and an extensive case of round and square slices. Office workers, tourists, and neighborhood regulars use it as their quick-stop spot for classic New York slices and grab-and-go Italian basics.

Must-Try Dishes: Round cheese slice, Buffalo chicken slice, Veggie pizza slice

What makes it special: Classic slice counter with a deep slice lineup and deli extras.

View Full Review →