Best Pizza Restaurants in Gramercy & Flatiron (10010)
5 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: January 2026
Our Top Pick
Stretch Pizza
A bar-driven slice shop with inventive pies and a polished room.
Notable Picks
8.4
A Flatiron slice-and-bar room that leans into crisp, thin pies with playful builds and a polished, hang-for-a-bit energy. It’s best when you order one classic anchor slice and one “idea” slice, then let the rest of the meal orbit around the bar-friendly pace.
Must-Try Dishes:
Everything Bagel Pizza, Oddfather, New York Pizza
What makes it special: A bar-driven slice shop with inventive pies and a polished room.
8.2
A Flatiron thin-crust specialist built for sharable pies, quick pacing, and a dependable dine-in rhythm that works for both lunch and casual nights. The move is to pick one bold pie and one straightforward baseline, then let the crunch and balance do the work.
Must-Try Dishes:
Meat Lovers Pizza, Truffle Mushroom Pizza, Cheese Pizza
What makes it special: Thin-crust pies that stay crisp and share cleanly.
8.0
Vibes:
Group Dining Gatherings
Trendy Table Hotspots
Comfort Food Classics
Business Lunch Power Players
A Flatiron Eataly sit-down that nails the reliable Italian comfort lane: Neapolitan-style pies and pasta with a steady, high-throughput dining-room rhythm. Treat it like a focused two-item mission—one pizza, one supporting plate—so the meal stays clean and satisfying.
Must-Try Dishes:
Margherita, Italian Sausage Pizza, Burrata
What makes it special: A busy Italian anchor where pizza and pasta stay dependable.
Worthy Picks
#4
Lucia Pizza
7.8
A Gramercy slice counter built for crisp, modern NYC slices with a few standout specialty options that reward a selective order. Go for one clean classic slice, then add a single signature specialty so the textures stay sharp and the meal doesn’t sprawl.
Must-Try Dishes:
Plain slice, Field Pig slice, Potato and Onion slice
What makes it special: A sharp slice program with a standout specialty rotation.
7.5
Vibes:
Late Night Legends
Quick Bites Champions
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Solo Dining Sanctuaries
A late-hours slice-and-hero stop that’s most valuable when you need Italian comfort fast, especially after most kitchens have slowed down. The move is simple: grab a couple of slices or a hot sandwich and treat it like a practical neighborhood option, not a destination pizzeria.
Must-Try Dishes:
Vodka slice, Chicken parm hero, Garlic knots
What makes it special: A true late-night Italian slice stop when most options are gone.