Any insider tips for The 4th Horseman?

Opened 2018 with arcade games including Mortal Kombat and Street Fighter II

What should I order at The 4th Horseman?

Death to Piggy, craft beer selection, sourdough garlic knots

When should I visit The 4th Horseman?

Friday-Saturday nights for full vibe experience

Who should go to The 4th Horseman?

Alternative crowds and horror enthusiasts seeking atmosphere

Any insider tips for Milana's New York Pizzeria?

Street parking has 15-minute free grace period for quick pickups

What should I order at Milana's New York Pizzeria?

Brooklyn Square with vodka sauce, classic pepperoni, white pizza

When should I visit Milana's New York Pizzeria?

Lunch for quick slices, dinner for fresh whole pies

Who should go to Milana's New York Pizzeria?

New Yorkers missing home, families wanting quality by-the-slice

Any insider tips for Baby Bros Pizza Downtown Long Beach?

Multiple locations but downtown spot has most interesting dining room

What should I order at Baby Bros Pizza Downtown Long Beach?

The Works with spicy sausage, Godfather, crispy potato wedges

When should I visit Baby Bros Pizza Downtown Long Beach?

Lunch or early dinner before bar crowd arrives

Who should go to Baby Bros Pizza Downtown Long Beach?

Families with older kids before evening, groups wanting substantial portions

Any insider tips for Buono's Authentic Pizzeria?

Family-style dinners feed groups with pizza and pasta combinations

What should I order at Buono's Authentic Pizzeria?

Pizza with hand-kneaded dough, homemade sausage standout

When should I visit Buono's Authentic Pizzeria?

Lunch for quick pizza or dinner for pasta specialties

Who should go to Buono's Authentic Pizzeria?

Budget-conscious families, authentic Italian seekers, lunch crowds

Any insider tips for Altar Society Brewing?

Historic architecture makes this more destination brewery than pizzeria

What should I order at Altar Society Brewing?

Award-winning IPA, any classic pizza, coffee drinks

When should I visit Altar Society Brewing?

Afternoon for coffee or evening for craft beers

Who should go to Altar Society Brewing?

Beer enthusiasts seeking food with their brews

Any insider tips for Canadian Pizza & Grill?

Small parking lot behind restaurant avoids street meter hassle

What should I order at Canadian Pizza & Grill?

Large 2-topping daily special, Italian calzone, veggie pizza

When should I visit Canadian Pizza & Grill?

Weekday lunch for $22 large 2-topping special

Who should go to Canadian Pizza & Grill?

Budget-conscious families, regulars wanting generous toppings without upcharges

Best Pizza Restaurants in Long Beach (90802)

6 hand-picked restaurants, AI-analyzed and critic-validated

Notable Picks

#1 The 4th Horseman

8.4

$$ Downtown Long Beach

Vibes: Instagram Worthy Wonders Date Night Magic Trendy Table Hotspots Late Night Legends

Horror-themed pizzeria with gothic macabre atmosphere featuring pizzas named after horror films, vintage arcade games, and extensive craft beer selection. House-made sourdough crust supports creative combinations like Memento Mori Bulgogi and Death to Piggy alongside vegan options.

Must-Try Dishes: Death to Piggy, Memento Mori Bulgogi Pizza, Hellfire Pizza

What makes it special: Unique horror-metal theme with pizzas named after horror icons

View Full Review →

#2 Milana's New York Pizzeria

8.3

$$ Downtown Long Beach

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Family Friendly Favorites Hidden Gems Heaven Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance

Authentic NYC-style pizzeria with subway-themed decor serving thin-crust pies by the slice or whole. Brooklyn Square pizza with vodka sauce and mascarpone stands out among traditional offerings approved by transplanted New Yorkers who drive long distances for these genuine flavors.

Must-Try Dishes: Brooklyn Square Pizza, Pepperoni Slice, Grandma Pizza

What makes it special: Real NYC-style pizza from Brooklyn native owner with authentic thin crust

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 Baby Bros Pizza Downtown Long Beach

7.9

$$ Downtown Long Beach

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Sports Bar Central Group Dining Gatherings Instagram Worthy Wonders

Pizzeria and sports bar combo in a visually striking space with eclectic decor and arcade games. The loaded specialty pizzas feature generous toppings and slightly spicy sausage, appealing to families during early hours before transitioning to bar atmosphere.

Must-Try Dishes: The Works Pizza, Godfather Pizza, Potato Wedges

What makes it special: Heavy, topping-loaded pizzas in striking interior with vintage arcade games

View Full Review →

#4 Buono's Authentic Pizzeria

7.9

$ Downtown Long Beach

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Comfort Food Classics

Family-owned since 1973 serving Old Country Italian pizzas with hand-kneaded dough, homemade sauces, and gas-fired brick ovens. Third-generation operation maintains patriarch Nicolaniello Buono's recipes from his 1967 arrival from Italy with generous portions.

Must-Try Dishes: Classic Pizza with Homemade Sauce, Lasagna, Eggplant Parmigiana

What makes it special: Three-generation family operation since 1967 with Old Country authenticity

View Full Review →

#5 Altar Society Brewing

7.8

$$ Downtown Long Beach

Vibes: Brewery & Beer Garden Republic Sports Bar Central Group Dining Gatherings Instagram Worthy Wonders

Historic 1903 Masonic Temple transformed into craft brewpub and coffee roaster with pizza menu. Award-winning lagers and IPAs paired with straightforward pies in prohibition-era setting with dark walnut tables and custom chandeliers overlooking brewing kettles.

Must-Try Dishes: Margherita Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza

What makes it special: Craft brewery in converted 1903 Masonic Temple with visible brew kettles

View Full Review →

#6 Canadian Pizza & Grill

7.6

$ Downtown Long Beach

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Hidden Gems Heaven

Family-owned neighborhood pizzeria since 2000 serving Canadian-style pizza with unique cornmeal crust alongside calzones, subs, and pasta dishes. The signature Canadian pizza loaded with pepperoni, Canadian bacon, green peppers, sausage, and choice of olives or feta remains the local favorite.

Must-Try Dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza, Veggie Pizza, Italian Calzone

What makes it special: Distinctive cornmeal crust recipe and exceptional value with enormous portions

View Full Review →