What is the best Pizza restaurant in Murray Hill & Kips Bay?

Norma is our top pick for Pizza restaurants in Murray Hill & Kips Bay, scoring 8.7/10. Sicilian-focused trattoria known for arancini, pasta alla Norma and warm hospitality.

Any insider tips for Norma?

Ask about daily specials; the kitchen often runs extra Sicilian plates.

What should I order at Norma?

Arancini, pasta alla Norma, a Rianata-style pan pizza.

When should I visit Norma?

Weeknights or early weekends for relaxed, unhurried dinners.

Who should go to Norma?

Italian comfort seekers who care about regional Sicilian touches.

Any insider tips for Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza?

Order a couple half-and-half pies to sample more of the specialty combinations.

What should I order at Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza?

Shroomtown pie, classic margherita, build-your-own thin crust.

When should I visit Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza?

Early dinner or late night to dodge peak waits.

Who should go to Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza?

Groups who like shareable, topping-loaded thin-crust pizzas.

Any insider tips for Garlic New York Pizza Bar?

Ask which grandma pies just came out of the oven; turnover is constant at peak hours.

What should I order at Garlic New York Pizza Bar?

Upside Down Grandma, truffle grandma slice, vodka square.

When should I visit Garlic New York Pizza Bar?

Late nights after the nearby bar scene or casual weeknights.

Who should go to Garlic New York Pizza Bar?

Night owls and locals wanting big, flavorful slices on a budget.

Any insider tips for Libretto's Pizzeria?

If you’re dining in, ask for pies well-done for extra crisp on the crust.

What should I order at Libretto's Pizzeria?

Grandma pie, New Yorker specialty pizza, chicken parm hero.

When should I visit Libretto's Pizzeria?

Lunch for slices or early evening for sit-down dinners.

Who should go to Libretto's Pizzeria?

Locals wanting reliable pies and red-sauce comfort dishes.

Any insider tips for Rocky's Pizzeria?

Head to the back room if you want a quieter sit-down experience than the front counter.

What should I order at Rocky's Pizzeria?

Penne alla vodka slice, grandma square, buffalo chicken slice.

When should I visit Rocky's Pizzeria?

Late nights or casual weekends when you want slices and space to sit.

Who should go to Rocky's Pizzeria?

Slice hunters looking for creative pasta-topped and grandma-style options.

Any insider tips for Little Italy Pizza ?

Scan the counter and pick slices that just hit the deck for best texture.

What should I order at Little Italy Pizza ?

Cheese slice, grandma square, pepperoni Sicilian.

When should I visit Little Italy Pizza ?

Off-peak mid-afternoon or late night to avoid heavy lines.

Who should go to Little Italy Pizza ?

People needing a fast, filling slice near Herald Square.

Any insider tips for NYC Pizza Kitchen?

Check combo deals; pie-and-wings or pie-and-salad specials improve value.

What should I order at NYC Pizza Kitchen?

Margherita pie, Sicilian square, garlic knots.

When should I visit NYC Pizza Kitchen?

Weeknights for quieter dine-in or game-night takeout runs.

Who should go to NYC Pizza Kitchen?

Kips Bay locals wanting dependable delivery or casual dine-in pizza.

Best Pizza Restaurants in Murray Hill & Kips Bay (10016)

7 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Norma

Sicilian-focused trattoria known for arancini, pasta alla Norma and warm hospitality.

Notable Picks

#1 Norma

8.7

$$ Murray Hill

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Date Night Magic Hidden Gems Heaven Family Friendly Favorites

Norma’s Murray Hill outpost leans into Sicilian comfort cooking, from arancini and panelle to richly sauced pasta alla Norma and pan-style pizzas. The cozy room and attentive staff make it a go-to for lingering dinners that feel more like a trattoria in Catania than a Third Avenue address.

Must-Try Dishes: Arancini Siciliani, Pasta alla Norma, Rianata Sicilian Pan Pizza

What makes it special: Sicilian-focused trattoria known for arancini, pasta alla Norma and warm hospitality.

View Full Review →

#2 Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza

8.6

$ Murray Hill

Vibes: Group Dining Gatherings Quick Bites Champions Family Friendly Favorites Trendy Table Hotspots

Vezzo has anchored Murray Hill’s pizza scene since 2006 with ultra-thin, cracker-crust pies baked to a shattering crisp. The crowded dining room and long-running popularity are driven by a wide roster of toppings that skew indulgent—think truffle, spicy sausage, and layered veggie combinations.

Must-Try Dishes: Shroomtown thin-crust pie with mushrooms and truffle oil, Margherita thin-crust pizza, Murray Hill pie with sausage and peppers

What makes it special: Long-running Murray Hill standby for ultra-thin, crispy pies with big toppings.

View Full Review →

#3 Garlic New York Pizza Bar

8.4

$$$ Murray Hill

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Late Night Legends Quick Bites Champions Group Dining Gatherings

Garlic New York Pizza Bar is a high-volume slice shop and bar hybrid in Murray Hill known for oversized squares and late-night hours. Regulars come for loaded grandma-style pies, garlic-heavy recipes, and a menu that runs from classic cheese to truffle and eggplant-topped slices.

Must-Try Dishes: Upside Down Grandma square with mozzarella under sauce, Truffle grandma slice, Eggplant-topped Sicilian slice

What makes it special: Busy slice counter and bar turning out hefty grandma pies deep into the night.

View Full Review →

#4 Libretto's Pizzeria

8.1

$$ Murray Hill

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance

Libretto's is a neighborhood pizzeria and Italian spot in Murray Hill balancing slices, whole pies, and red-sauce classics. It functions as an all-purpose option where residents grab a quick slice at the counter or sit down for bigger New Yorker-style pies and chicken parms.

Must-Try Dishes: Grandma square pie, New Yorker pie with pepperoni and sausage, Vodka slice with fresh mozzarella

What makes it special: Neighborhood standby offering both New York slices and full Italian dinners under one roof.

View Full Review →

#5 Rocky's Pizzeria

8.0

$ Kips Bay

Vibes: Hidden Gems Heaven Late Night Legends Quick Bites Champions Comfort Food Classics

Rocky’s is an old-school Kips Bay pizzeria with counter slices up front and a surprisingly spacious back room for lingering over pies. Beyond classic cheese, it’s known for over-the-top specialty slices like penne alla vodka pizza and grandma squares that draw a loyal late-night crowd.

Must-Try Dishes: Penne alla vodka pizza slice, Grandma square slice, Buffalo chicken slice

What makes it special: Long-running slice shop with a brick-oven feel and a huge roster of specialty pies.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#6 Little Italy Pizza

7.9

$ Midtown South

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Late Night Legends Group Dining Gatherings

The Little Italy Pizza outpost near 33rd Street funnels a steady Midtown crowd through its long counter of classic and specialty slices. It’s a fast-moving, no-frills operation where commuters and office workers grab foldable New York slices, Sicilian squares, and garlic knot add-ons.

Must-Try Dishes: Classic cheese slice, Grandma square with garlic and basil, Pepperoni Sicilian slice

What makes it special: High-traffic slice shop steps from transit with a big lineup of classic and square pies.

View Full Review →

#7 NYC Pizza Kitchen

7.8

$ Kips Bay

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Quick Bites Champions Comfort Food Classics Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance

NYC Pizza Kitchen in Kips Bay is a sit-down and takeout shop with a broad New York–style pizza menu plus slices, stromboli, and pastas. It fills the role of a reliable neighborhood option where you can order a straightforward pie, try thicker Sicilian squares, or tack on a salad and wings.

Must-Try Dishes: Margherita pie, Sicilian square pizza, BBQ chicken pizza

What makes it special: Neighborhood pizza shop balancing classic pies, Sicilian slices, and a fuller Italian menu.

View Full Review →