Best Pizza Restaurants in Pleasanton (94566)
7 hand-picked restaurants, AI-analyzed and critic-validated
Essential Picks
9.1
This Shakespeare-themed carry-out pizzeria earned a spot on Yelp's 2025 Top 100 restaurants with its award-winning house-made sourdough crust that ferments for 72 hours. The mom-and-pop shop, opened by retired teachers in 2022, secured 2nd place at the Pizza Tomorrow Summit for their traditional sauce.
Must-Try Dishes:
Spinach & Mushroom Stuffed, Henry the 8th Pizza, Capulet Pizza
What makes it special: Award-winning 72-hour fermented sourdough crust with no added sugar
Notable Picks
8.8
Employee-owned since 1983, this East Bay institution brings authentic Chicago-style stuffed pizzas to downtown Pleasanton with over 225 best pizza awards. Their signature spinach and mushroom stuffed pizza features layers of cheese and toppings between two crusts, plus they offer excellent thin-crust options.
Must-Try Dishes:
Spinach & Mushroom Stuffed, Zachary Special, Mediterranean Pizza
What makes it special: Authentic Chicago-style stuffed pizzas with California twist
8.4
Serving Pleasanton since 1959, this Tri-Valley Herald award winner crafts sourdough specialty pizzas from scratch in a vintage-themed parlor. The family-friendly restaurant combines six decades of tradition with consistently fresh ingredients and that distinctive sourdough tang locals have loved for generations.
Must-Try Dishes:
Sourdough Specialty Pizza, Gourmet Combination, Classic Pepperoni
What makes it special: 65-year legacy with award-winning sourdough crust
8.1
Vibes:
Sports Bar Central
Brewery & Beer Garden Republic
Group Dining Gatherings
Instagram Worthy Wonders
This sports bar pizzeria uniquely blends traditional and Indian fusion pizzas with 50+ craft beers on tap across wall-to-wall TVs. Standout offerings include butter chicken and tandoori pizzas alongside classics, making it the go-to spot for game day with a twist.
Must-Try Dishes:
Butter Chicken Pizza, Tandoori Wings, Pepperoni Paradise
What makes it special: Indian fusion pizzas with 50+ craft beers on tap
Worthy Picks
7.9
This upscale Italian restaurant brings Neapolitan thin-crust pizzas crafted by a certified Master Pizzaiolo from Naples alongside house-made pastas and small plates. Part of the Locanda restaurant group, it offers authentic Italian hospitality with a full bar and charming patio dining.
Must-Try Dishes:
Margherita Pizza, Diavola Pizza, Prosciutto e Arugula
What makes it special: Certified Master Pizzaiolo from Naples
7.8
This corner pizzeria has anchored north Main Street since 1992, serving authentic New York-style thin crust by the slice or whole pie until late night. Known for generous toppings including 12 oz of steak on medium pizzas, they stay open until 2am on weekends for the late-night crowd.
Must-Try Dishes:
Brooklyn Bridge Special, By-the-Slice Pepperoni, Steak Pizza
What makes it special: Authentic NY-style open until 2am weekends
#7
PBX Pizza
7.6
This newer Indian fusion pizzeria brings bold Punjabi flavors to classic pies with options like butter chicken and paneer tikka pizzas at budget-friendly prices. The small, vibrant space honors Punjabi culture while serving halal options and gluten-free crusts.
Must-Try Dishes:
Butter Chicken Pizza, Paneer Tikka Pizza, Tandoori Chicken Pizza
What makes it special: Authentic Punjabi-Indian fusion at affordable prices