Best Sandwiches Restaurants in Highland Park (90042)
5 hand-picked restaurants, AI-analyzed and critic-validated
Notable Picks
Maciel’s reimagines the neighborhood deli with fully plant-based meats and cheeses made in-house, turning classics like the Reuben and Italian sub into LA-worthy sandwiches. The compact Highland Park space stays busy with locals and destination diners who come for bold flavors, thoughtful sourcing, and a menu that feels indulgent while still being veggie-forward.
Must-Try Dishes:
The Italian, The Californian, Reuben
What makes it special: A true vegan butcher shop turning deli classics into plant-based standouts.
8.4
Ggiata’s Highland Park outpost brings East Coast Italian deli swagger to York with overstuffed hot and cold sandwiches on charred seeded baguettes. The narrow dining room, mosaic floors, and counter seating make it a lively spot for saucy, crunchy chicken cutlets and classic Italian combos.
Must-Try Dishes:
Spicy P, The Masterpiece, The Classic Italian
What makes it special: East Coast–style Italian deli sandwiches with serious crunch and sauce.
8.3
Belle’s Delicatessen & Bar turns the beloved Belle’s Bagels pop-up into a full-on Jewish deli and nighttime hangout, with double-fermented bagels, hefty pastrami sandwiches, and cocktails like the pickle martini. The room blends vintage memorabilia with a busy bar, making it as good for a late-night Reuben as a brunchy bacon-egg-and-cheese.
Must-Try Dishes:
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel, Reuben, Westlake Sandwich
What makes it special: An all-day Jewish deli where serious bagel sandwiches meet a real bar.
8.2
Kitchen Mouse is a vegetarian, gluten-free cafe that treats sandwiches with the same care as its bowls and brunch plates, from the tempeh Reuben to stacked breakfast sandwiches on griddled gluten-free bread. Bright, cozy interiors and a leafy patio draw steady lines of families, veg-forward eaters, and neighborhood regulars.
Must-Try Dishes:
Tempeh Reuben Sandwich, Jo's Breakfast Sandwich, Avocado TLT
What makes it special: A health-conscious cafe where gluten-free, vegetarian sandwiches actually feel indulgent.
Worthy Picks
7.8
The Highland Cafe is a neighborhood standby where locals fuel up on strong coffee, hefty breakfast burritos, and classic breakfast sandwiches. Skateboards on the wall, a casual crowd, and dog-friendly sidewalk seating make it a relaxed, slightly scruffy spot for a quick York Boulevard sandwich stop.
Must-Try Dishes:
Bacon Egg & Cheese Sandwich, Breakfast Burrito, Cali Burrito with Rojo Fries
What makes it special: A laid-back cafe with legitimately craveable breakfast sandwiches and burritos.