What is the best Sandwiches restaurant in Midtown East?

JoJu is our top pick for Sandwiches restaurants in Midtown East, scoring 8.6/10. Modern Vietnamese banh mi and bowls with serious flavor and speed.

Any insider tips for JoJu?

Order ahead online to skip the kiosk line during peak lunch.

When should I visit JoJu?

Weekday lunch rush for peak energy and fresh bread.

Who should go to JoJu?

Office workers craving upgraded banh mi and loaded fries.

Any insider tips for Little Collins?

Mobile-order during peak lunch; counter pickup beats the walk-up line.

When should I visit Little Collins?

Early lunch or mid-morning before peak caffeine rush.

Who should go to Little Collins?

Midtown workers wanting better-than-deli sandwiches and coffee.

Any insider tips for Sandwicherie of New York?

Use their online ordering for large office or train-time pickups.

When should I visit Sandwicherie of New York?

Pre-noon or mid-afternoon to avoid Grand Central crush.

Who should go to Sandwicherie of New York?

Commuters wanting fresher sandwiches than generic delis.

Any insider tips for Pickler Sandwich Shop?

Portions are big; split a sandwich and add fries if budgeting.

What should I order at Pickler Sandwich Shop?

Turkey Club, Rachel Sandwich, Avo Grilled Cheese.

When should I visit Pickler Sandwich Shop?

Slightly before noon or after one for shorter lines.

Who should go to Pickler Sandwich Shop?

Sandwich traditionalists craving Reubens, clubs and melty grills.

Best Sandwiches Restaurants in Midtown East (10017)

Q: What should I order at JoJu?

The Sweet (JoJu) Banh Mi, Caramel Pork Bowl, JoJu Fries.

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

JoJu

Modern Vietnamese banh mi and bowls with serious flavor and speed.

Notable Picks

#1 JoJu

8.6

$$ Midtown East – Fifth Avenue Corridor

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Solo Dining Sanctuaries Hidden Gems Heaven

JoJu’s Midtown outpost brings the Elmhurst-born banh mi shop to 5th Avenue with modern Vietnamese sandwiches, rice bowls, and loaded fries built for office-hour lunches. Fans praise the crackly bread, deeply marinated proteins, and efficient counter system that keeps lines moving even at peak weekday rush.

Must-Try Dishes: The Sweet (JoJu) Banh Mi, Caramel Pork Bowl, JoJu Fries

What makes it special: Modern Vietnamese banh mi and bowls with serious flavor and speed.

View Full Review →

#2 Little Collins

8.5

$$ Midtown East – Grand Central / 3rd Avenue Corridor

Vibes: Brunch Bliss Spots Quick Bites Champions Solo Dining Sanctuaries Trendy Table Hotspots

An Australian-style café a few blocks from Grand Central, Little Collins turns out serious sandwiches and breakfast rolls alongside specialty coffee in a tight, always-busy space. Since opening its first Midtown shop in 2013, it’s become a regulars’ spot for well-built egg sandwiches, BLATs and fried chicken on real bread instead of generic deli rolls.

Must-Try Dishes: The Pick Me Up, Dash's Fried Chicken Sandwich, B.L.A.T.

What makes it special: Australian-inspired café where coffee-shop sandwiches are treated with restaurant-level care.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 Sandwicherie of New York

7.9

$ Midtown East – Grand Central / 42nd Street

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Healthy Haven Quick Bites Champions

Steps from Grand Central, Sandwicherie of New York is an all-day café where office regulars rely on customizable salads and toasted sandwiches rather than generic steam-table fare. The menu leans surprisingly fresh, with avocado-heavy veggie builds and grilled chicken options that travel well back to a desk or train.

Must-Try Dishes: Spicy Chic Sandwich, Adobo Chicken Sandwich, Avocado Veggie Sandwich

What makes it special: High-throughput Grand Central café doing made-to-order sandwiches with a health-conscious tilt.

View Full Review →

#4 Pickler Sandwich Shop

7.8

$$$$ Midtown East – Grand Central / 45th Street Corridor

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Comfort Food Classics Quick Bites Champions Solo Dining Sanctuaries

On East 45th between 2nd and 3rd, Pickler is a compact counter-service shop focused on hefty deli-style sandwiches with better bread and sharper toppings than most Midtown chains. Regulars praise the Reuben, turkey club and pickle-forward twists that make it a reliable, slightly indulgent lunch stop.

Must-Try Dishes: Turkey Club Sandwich, Rachel Sandwich, Avo Grilled Cheese

What makes it special: Tight Midtown deli turning out stacked classics with standout pickles and pressed sandwiches.

View Full Review →