What is the best Seafood restaurant in Soho?

Blue Ribbon Brasserie is our top pick for Seafood restaurants in Soho, scoring 8.8/10. Iconic late-night SoHo brasserie for fried chicken, marrow, and a serious raw bar.

Any insider tips for Blue Ribbon Brasserie?

Solo diners can often snag a late walk-in spot at the bar.

What should I order at Blue Ribbon Brasserie?

Fried chicken, bone marrow with oxtail marmalade, seafood plateau.

When should I visit Blue Ribbon Brasserie?

Late evenings into the early hours for full energy.

Who should go to Blue Ribbon Brasserie?

Night owls, industry folks, and classic brasserie obsessives.

Any insider tips for Fish Cheeks?

Book early and plan to share; spice levels run authentically high.

What should I order at Fish Cheeks?

Coconut crab curry, whole steamed fish, crab fried rice.

When should I visit Fish Cheeks?

Prime dinner hours for full buzz and fresh specials.

Who should go to Fish Cheeks?

Groups and couples craving bold Thai seafood.

Any insider tips for Lure Fishbar?

Sit at the sushi bar if you want the best view of the action.

What should I order at Lure Fishbar?

Oysters, crispy sushi rice, lobster mac and cheese.

When should I visit Lure Fishbar?

Busy dinner hours or late-night for peak energy.

Who should go to Lure Fishbar?

Seafood lovers willing to splurge in a scene-y room.

Any insider tips for Mermaid Oyster Bar?

Time your visit around happy hour for the best value on oysters.

What should I order at Mermaid Oyster Bar?

Daily oysters, lobster roll, lobster knuckles & knuckles.

When should I visit Mermaid Oyster Bar?

Weekday happy hour or early evening before peak rush.

Who should go to Mermaid Oyster Bar?

Oyster fans and couples wanting cozy seafood.

Any insider tips for The Otter?

Enter through The Manner’s lobby and ask for a table near the murals for the best sense of the room.

What should I order at The Otter?

Scallop crudo, crab agnolotti, swordfish frites.

When should I visit The Otter?

Dinner or weekend brunch when the room feels most alive.

Who should go to The Otter?

Diners chasing inventive seafood in a tucked-away setting.

Best Seafood Restaurants in Soho (10012)

5 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Blue Ribbon Brasserie

Iconic late-night SoHo brasserie for fried chicken, marrow, and a serious raw bar.

Notable Picks

#1 Blue Ribbon Brasserie

8.8

$$$ SoHo

Vibes: Date Night Magic Late Night Legends Group Dining Gatherings Trendy Table Hotspots

Bruce and Eric Bromberg’s Blue Ribbon Brasserie has anchored SoHo’s late-night dining scene since 1992, pairing a deep raw bar and bone marrow with what many consider some of the city’s definitive fried chicken. High multi-platform ratings and thousands of reviews over three decades support its status as a reliable go-to for chefs, industry regulars, and night-owl diners alike.

Must-Try Dishes: Fried Chicken with Mashed Potatoes & Collard Greens, Beef Marrow with Oxtail Marmalade, Seafood Plateau with Oysters & Shellfish

What makes it special: Iconic late-night SoHo brasserie for fried chicken, marrow, and a serious raw bar.

View Full Review →

#2 Fish Cheeks

8.7

$$ NoHo

Vibes: Date Night Magic Group Dining Gatherings Trendy Table Hotspots

Fish Cheeks is a high-energy NoHo spot for Thai-style seafood served family-style, from coconut crab curry to whole steamed fish drenched in herbs and chile. Diners come for bold flavors, shareable platters, and cocktails in a room that feels more like a busy Bangkok dinner party than a quiet neighborhood meal.

Must-Try Dishes: Coconut Crab Curry, Steamed Whole Fish with Thai Herbs, Crab Fried Rice

What makes it special: Thai seafood cooked with big, spicy, shareable flavors in a lively room.

View Full Review →

#3 Lure Fishbar

8.6

$$$ SoHo

Vibes: Birthday & Celebration Central Business Lunch Power Players Date Night Magic Trendy Table Hotspots

Lure Fishbar is a subterranean SoHo seafood and sushi restaurant styled like a sleek yacht, with a deep raw bar, polished nigiri, and indulgent mains like lobster mac and cheese. It draws fashion and media crowds for celebratory dinners, power sushi at the bar, and late-night shellfish platters.

Must-Try Dishes: Lobster Mac and Cheese, Hellfire Roll, Crispy Sushi Rice with Spicy Tuna

What makes it special: Yacht-like SoHo dining room pairing raw bar, sushi, and glitzy seafood classics.

View Full Review →

#4 Mermaid Oyster Bar

8.6

$$$ Greenwich Village

Vibes: Date Night Magic Happy Hour Hotspots Group Dining Gatherings Trendy Table Hotspots

Mermaid Oyster Bar brings a polished coastal raw bar to MacDougal Street, with rotating oysters, lobster rolls, and seafood plates in a narrow, warmly lit space. Locals lean on it for happy hour shellfish, date-night seafood dinners, and reliable service that keeps the room humming.

Must-Try Dishes: Happy Hour Oysters, New England-Style Lobster Roll, Lobster Knuckles & Knuckles

What makes it special: Greenwich Village raw bar with serious oysters, lobster rolls, and a coastal vibe.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#5 The Otter

7.9

$$$ SoHo

Vibes: Date Night Magic Brunch Bliss Spots Hidden Gems Heaven

Tucked inside The Manner hotel, The Otter does New England-leaning seafood with a chef-y twist, from crab agnolotti under Ritz crumbs to swordfish frites in a glossy peppercorn sauce. A dim, Art Deco-inspired room and a seafood-focused cocktail list make it feel like a quietly ambitious SoHo hideaway.

Must-Try Dishes: Crab Agnolotti with Ritz Crumble, Swordfish Frites au Poivre, Scallop Crudo

What makes it special: Hotel dining room where playful, high-low seafood dishes meet moody Art Deco design.

View Full Review →